your thoughts

😂 they should listen to us ✅ we know what we are talking about 😛

i think u guys might b right about the "three broomsticks forum" but i stick to the idea of the "question thread" cause all newbies 4 example want to know.... say when HP6 is comin' out so they just open a thread about it, so if we have a question thread, in the first page they'll just go there, cause i've seen that newbies most of the time open question threads no discussions threads but questions, that's y i agree the idea of the question forum,
but hell that's just my opinion and i guess i have to agree with the three broomsticks thingy (that it will destroy our forum) ands if ppl wants to talk about whatever jst go to the tig party or off topic forum

I like the Three Broomsticks.

i like it too! but the other guys say iot might destroy our forums and mayb that might b right and we for sure don't want that right?

might be right?

we ARE

right.

you know those films where some people want to do something- but sombody has had experience with it before and they say 'nooo dont do it' and they dont listen----then everyone dies.

go figure

lol... u cannot b 100 % sure ok! 'cause this is not the LotR forum is HP so it's possible that even though we have a pointless chat ppl will still post in their common rooms and participate in the challenges, and i'm sorry experience?? LotR it does not mean u have experience.

A social thread may ruin this forum, but it way not. There's almost nothing to talk about at the LotR forum, but there are still 2 books and more movies left here, so discussions can still continue

so what da ya think? we should open a social thread or not?

NO

i DO have experience

this forum is kinda slow to start with- open a social thread and BOOM there goes other threads.

you might think it keeps all the pointlessness in that thread
but it doesnt trust me.

Here's my view on the topic...

Point 1-- if people want to ask questions
There are different types of questions--
1. simple questions about the upcoming books: There are official threads for each of the books
2. simple questions about POA-- there's an official thread for that as well
3. questions about auditioning for roles-- there are millions of threads for that
4. deep, thought-provoking questions that can lead to interesting discussions: those earn an entire thread to themselves, for EVERYONE, not just those who would visit the social thread, to part-take in these real discussions
5. threads about the actors-- there is an official thread for this as well
6. threads about the characters-- yeah, official thread here, again

And, I have the links to most of these "official" threads if anyone wants them.

Point 2--
These same newbies who come in the forum and make new pointless, dup threads are not guaranteed to visit the social thread-- In the same way they bypass the Rules thread, they can easily bypass our social thread

Point 3--
The creation of a social thread in the lotr forum has maimed the rest of our interesting threads-- only our game threads remain active now

On this forum, however, the problem is not a lack of a social thread-- but of people who are too lazy to search for a topic, or who start pointless, unnecessary, or unrelated topics.

Therefore, my point is-- a social thread can do us no good, really.

2day i visited the lottr forum and even though it had a social thread tehre were tons of other threads with the NEW note above them

Yeah, but you were just visiting

Trust us, who practically live there

LOL ok trust u guys! 😉

new to you yes-every thread in this ofrum has a new one cos i havent read the replied

what?

oh ok get it

whoah i made so many typos

we have gained more votes 😛 it's 5 of us now saying no...

I agree with the points Tas made ✅

i agree with Suro

😂 Course you do...

i agree with him too 😛