Maybe this?

if he killed the grown up harry first. wouldnt he have come out the wand?

no because for that to happen harry would have to have already gone back and be killed

i dont know how to explain it, its time- its unexplainable

sombody get my good mate stephen in here, nothing good old mr hawes cant explain

i though the missing death eater was SNAPE.................. cuz he's playing both sides (in a way...but ultimately on the good side)

Snape-the one who betrayed him-
Karkaroff- the one who deserted him

but im sure there was more than two missing spaces

I wouldn't doubt.......

Hey Y'all

My sister and I were debating the other night what might happen during the sixth and seventh books. We figured that the time turner may be involved.

Since harry knows about the time turner, common sense would tell us that he'd at least be interested in going back in time to try to kill voldy before he kills James and Lily. But being that, in the third book, that what happened in 'realtime' and while they were using the time turner happened at the exact same time, my theory would not work. Because James & Lily came out of Voldy's wand, and if Harry did go back and do that, then he would not have a scar, and the history of Harry Potter as we know it would be so much different--and that's not happening at the same time. As a matter of fact, why would Harry be smiling while Voldy was approaching him? Maybe he saw someone else?

But just think-- the time turner and the order of the phoenix; what about Neville? What will the Harry Potter club's involvement be? The possibilities are so mind boggling, I cannot see straight.

What about if a wizard or two dies while being 'pollyjuiced'--would the pollyjuiced version of the wizard preserve and come out of the wand? Maybe Harry was able to get his parents into hiding and got two people to sacrifice their lives with the pollyjuice potion, and then let voldy do his thing to Harry.

Speaking of wandless magic, doesn't harry potter do that at home during the summer?

Harru for his dad
and hermy for his mam because harry nd hermy couple up 😉 😛

What about snape and karkaroff? Just a thought...

Originally posted by celestial_moon
actually, if u have a copy of the hardcover 4th book u can c that james comes out then lily. then in the paperback version, lily comes out then james.

But then the story must be a bit different! in the hard cover, James comes out and says something like"Your mothers coming, she wants to see you..."
What does Lily say when she comes out first in the Paperback version?

Oops, sorry 😮 I should have read through the whole thread before posting. I know the answer now, so don't bother answering me. 😄

Ya, it was just an editing mistake on JK's side of things, prolly wrote it at 4 in the morning and wasnt paying attention lol

All sounds like really cool info ( mistakes could happen for a reason )