Cap has absolutely no advantage here. The only possible way he could eke out a win is if Midnighter looked at him and decided to give up without fighting because they know how good or noble Cap is, which has historically happened several times. He can beat competent guys faster, stronger and more agile than him... if he knows their fighting style completely, e.g. Beast, Spiderman... but against Midnighter???
Midnighter 9/10
Originally posted by D_Dude1210Cap won because he knows exactly how Spiderman fights as explained in Civil War. And Cap has enough speed, strength and skill to utilize that advantage against Spiderman. He doesn't know Midnighter. And while Cap's one of the best, he's not good enough.
Cap has the strongest jobber aura there is, swhy he's been seen to beat Spiderman. There should been no way he even stood remotely a chance against Spiderman, Peter woulda hit him 20 times before he even knew to swing his arm. :-/