which of the 3 LOTR WAS THE BEST and THE WORSE?

I love all three LOTR movies, even though PJ left out tons of great stuff that was in the book, he did a great job.

And, hopefully, the Scouring of the Shire part in ROTK will be in the ROTK EE DVD.....hopefully....😕

it better or that would be a rip off

Seriously. That's one of the parts I was looking forward to seeing on the movie screen....And it turned out it wasn't 🙁 PJ better have put it in the EE.

Dejio you put it amazingly well!!

I agree all three films are absoulutly amazing, i love them all
'
And oh yes i agree about scouring of the shire, it better be on the extended, IT HAS TO BE, im looking foward to seeing that! Ive read it in the book and omg, i was like: AH it has to be in the extended

but i heard they didnt even film scouring of the shire, which THEY BETTER HAVE!! isnt the bit where frodo is looking in the mirror of galadrial, and it shows the shire burning and them taking them hostage, isnt that somewhat to the scouring of the shire? I kept wondering that

hostage...lol that sounded funny

orcs taking them hostage* ah typos

Originally posted by OrliNElijahsGrl
Dejio you put it amazingly well!!

I agree all three films are absoulutly amazing, i love them all
'
And oh yes i agree about scouring of the shire, it better be on the extended, IT HAS TO BE, im looking foward to seeing that! Ive read it in the book and omg, i was like: AH it has to be in the extended

but i heard they didnt even film scouring of the shire, which THEY BETTER HAVE!! isnt the bit where frodo is looking in the mirror of galadrial, and it shows the shire burning and them taking them hostage, isnt that somewhat to the scouring of the shire? I kept wondering that

How could the Scouring be in it?
It won't, because Saruman doesn't die that way.
Plus, how the hell, if you'd filmed the Scouring, leave it out of the theatrical version?!>!>!

I have no idea, i was just wondering if itd be included in the extended, cause it was to me a real good part of the book, i liked reading it

I dunno, the same with them filming some other stuff and not putting it in theatrical version and putting it on extended, so maybe scouring will be on there, maybe it wont, but ive heard scouring wasnt even filmed, so who knows

Im just hoping though, in hope that maybe it was filmed and being put in the extended, im just hoping, no hurt in hoping

why are you jumping all over me anyways?

STOP SPAMMING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Use your Edit button, OrliNElijahsGrl.

Favourite/Best Scene/Movie