it's hard to say which hp book is the best. i like cos because it had a lot of dark mystery. poa introduced the marauders. gof might be the best before the ootp existed. harry had to face a lot of challenges in life: fighting with a friend, the triwizard tournament, death eaters, and people out to get him. i could never really, or took the time, to think which character i could most relate to, until i read the fifth book. i haven't finished. from what i read so far of book 5, all those frustrating moments harry has and things he does to get it off his mind, i can relate. besides ron's fear of spiders. ~lol~ only i'm not as much a sissy as he. ^.~
battosai yuriko
i love all the books, in order :
3rd - cuz of moony. he rules over all characters. luv him
4th n 5th - cuz there so intense, and the 5th is so....dark. everyones so angry and the 4th is just dam good
1st - cuz i love the intro (i know it off by heart, the first page n a bit neway.) and it was the first.
2nd - was alrite, but it just wasnt as good as the others. i agree with frootlooplucy, it was ... meh
im undecided between 3, 4 and 5... 3 because it had so many twists and surprises (sirius being innocent, wormtail being scabbers etc) 4 coz it was so exciting with the trwizard tournament, and coz Voldie came back, and 5 coz its the most recent and still fresh and exciting, but also coz it was really good. you all bored to death now? good good🙂