wait...that makes no sense, yes the troll stabbed him in the stomach, and the mithril protected him from that and yes its a low cut top kind of mithril shirt, but it looks to me that shelob stabs him in the stomach..not on the shoulder...but in the book it says he was stabbed in the neck or...maybe it was the shoulder, but in the film, it def. looks like he was stabbed in the stomach, AND...just to point out...during the sneak attack that shelob does and frodo is looking around, it doesnt look like he even has the mithril shirt on, cause i remember being able to see it at the beginning of ROTK but during that part where shelob does the sneak attack, it looks like frodo doesnt even have the mithril on! lol
ahhhhh confusion
Maybe there is something we missed, that we will be able to see in the extended, cause maybe he does take it off for some reason, cause i swear to you, the many zooming and rewinding and looking close that ive done on that part, i see no mithril shirt AT ALL, like his shirt is sort of like low cut, and at the beginning, u were able to see some of the mithril, but during the sneak attack from shelob, theres that wide shot, i saw no mithril shirt, just skin! LOL
By the way...witchys stab was on the right! it was on the right shoulder, i REMEMBER, cause i see frodo laying there and getting stabbed, and also..he clutches his right shoulder all the time, expecially when witchy comes out and screeches, he goes "I can feel his blade" and hes rubbing his...RIGHT SHOULDER! lol
Merge?
😬
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=295451&perpage=40
One of you obviously saw the films mirrored 😛
It's on the left side.
... ok, a pic won't help much as it could be mirrored as well 😛
But it IS on the left side
Remember - one of the splinters nearly reached the heart, and *most* people have their hearts a little more on the left side 😛
Ooooo i get the witchy stab now! BUT now im curious about the shelob stabbing!
RIGHT HERE...in a script of ROTK
it says...Shelob stabs him quickly somewhere around his torso and lower body.
see!!! but wheres the wound mark when you see him shirtless and tied up?! you dont see it...ahh this is all too confusing
Thoronder, its okay, im just trying to understand it, cause its been bugging me now...OKAY now i get that IF he was stabbed in the stomach or torso, how the mithril wouldnt of saved him, but now my question is...wheres the wound mark on his stomach where hes tied up and shirtless? if they made the wound mark on his shoulder to represent the shelob stabbing then they should of had her stab him the shoulder instead of having her stab him in the stomach, which basically where it looks like she stabs him! LOL this is all confusing