New person in LOTR stories:Christina

Started by Dexx5 pages

I'm suyre u know what malformation is.
Another thing...the film's director can consider certain problems before launching it. This film, besides satisfying some fan's wishes, it's supposed to make money. And so far it did. The film was long enough as it was and details would make it even longer. The film realy turned out ok. It made me want to read the books. I liked the books, and i liked the movie too

as much as I love to praise good Tom Bombadil, old Ushgarak has a point with him not being important to the story, plus maybe difficult to get anything good off on a film, so it's okay that they cut him out. they HAVE to limit the length some, they just can't let it go on for ages, no matter how much some fans would want it.

hmm...i consider Tom Bombadil being rather important...not in the main picture but still. maybe Tolkien wants to to say something with him being imune to the ring

I am so sorry that you missed the point 😈
the point is that the film is a work of art , but art should be aimed at a small minority like .......me........ and I can critasise it for being too short just like the book which also was critasised for being too short and at the same time by some? too long.

P>S I can not spell critasize
this thread is getting back to the point good remake the film( just for me please)

people with bad rabbits should not write poertry 😛 😛 😛 🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣

no more rabbits they can not write

well.. if ur polite and ask them nicely, i'm sure they can make the movie again just for you 🙂

you have quite an imagination.........
oh,and BTW,welcome 😄

It is not my imagination 😠 😠 rabbits can not write!!!
how do I ask them(?) who is them(?) is this a conspiracy theory braeking out(?) why do I keep putting question marks in brackets(?)

Back to the main topic If u visit(www.j.r.r.toilkien articles)
u will be treated to many essays about LOTR and in one about who is tom(quite long but worth it) it places tom in a new light as one of the
vala.
goldberry is also cast in another light.

[QUOTE]people should not cast glass rabits in stone houses 😮‍💨 😄

Tom being a Vala is only one of many theories being discussed though, what he really is have, and never will, be revealed.
you might want to read this essay about the subject for detailed speculations and breakdowns of many theories.

I tryied but the screen would not come up, will try again later many thanks 😎 😎 🙂

[QUOTE]people with glass rabbits should not throw them .

Hey I got in thanks again
o.k. now for the deep bit

they have stated that tom could not be a vala because glorfindel said that he did not have the power to over come sauron but as with morgorth and sauron they each put out of themselves great parts of thier power(the ring) which deminished them , if the vala where trying to save middle earth the only way they could was by putting thier power out, thus they ,near the end where not powerful enough to overcome sauron AND his army alone thus the statement may not be water tight

ME THINKS

[QUOTE]people who write rabbit stories in glass houses should just throw them away

maybe..but it's all very complicated, and since JRR never revealed what Tom was, we'll never know I guess

How can u end with we,ll never know ? it sort of kills the thread 😛 😛 😛

[QUOTE]bl**dy rabbits they get every where 😮‍💨

it's a fact though🙂
JRR aren't here anymore to tell the truth

Who are we mortals to say what truth is 😮‍💨 😮‍💨

[QUOTE]Have you seen my bl**dy rabbit about? it has big ears and big teeth, 😮‍💨 😮‍💨

hehe, who is anyone to say what truth is, cause truth is just a way to look at things, we all harbour a different truth and we will all be as convinced that truth is THE turth

truth is ,and i want to make this clear, truth is objective and open to debate.(thank you)
😮‍💨

RABBITS ALL THE WAY 😉

u sure u mean objectif and not subjectif?
cause I've got a hard time picturing how something objectif can be open for debat

DO YOU REMEMBER THE GOOD OLD DAYS WHEN THIE THREAD HAD A DIRECTION AND A MEANING, ?
WHERE DO THREADS GO WHEN THEY DIE? 😕 😕

[QUOTE]people who read their own poertry out loud may have other bad habbits

huh? I ain't following what u mean by thie threads

and I think threads go to a lil space deep by the core of the earth, where they lay for an eternity waiting for the prince of darkness to take them back to the real world and plung it into darkness and chaos 😈