is harry insane

what if in the next book it is realized that harry is actual insane. that he realy does attend st brunos. that hogwarts and the intire magical comunity is harry's hallucination. a good way for the next book to begin is to have harry wake up in a hospital bed and not know where he is.

that would be sad. . . and dissapointing

and i think YOU are insane

poor Harry thats a scary thought JK please dont do that the poor boy's been through enough.

thats interesting...it would be a real twist, but I think it wouldn't be too pleasing for fans......

very true Maybeth

yes this wouldn't be to pleasing however it would make the storie better i think most endings are forseeable. everyone expects good to triumph over evil in the end. my own opinion is that if the ending isn't something completely unexpected then the stories will lose something as an all. one coment to tigress is if the stories thus far are all in harrys head then harry realy hasn't been through anything.

in his head he would've been nightmares can screw with your head be it insanity or bad dreams though

Originally posted by KillumAll
what if in the next book it is realized that harry is actual insane. that he realy does attend st brunos. that hogwarts and the intire magical comunity is harry's hallucination. a good way for the next book to begin is to have harry wake up in a hospital bed and not know where he is.

thats a killer idea. Fight Club style. Too bad that movie sucked.

there was theory similar to this.... this is wut i could remeber of it.... Harry was a baby. He was sleeping in his carrige and as u know he awoke, grew up, found out he is a wizard and so on. But wut if he never actully awoke and this is all a dream. and at the end of book 7 he is is awokeem.

i really hope this theory is incorrect. and it probaly is.

there was theory similar to this.... this is wut i could remeber of it.... Harry was a baby. He was sleeping in his carrige and as u know he awoke, grew up, found out he is a wizard and so on. But wut if he never actully awoke and this is all a dream. and at the end of book 7 he is is awokeem.

i really hope this theory is incorrect. and it probaly is.

woops.. sorry about the double post

Originally posted by DanZeke25
there was theory similar to this.... this is wut i could remeber of it.... Harry was a baby. He was sleeping in his carrige and as u know he awoke, grew up, found out he is a wizard and so on. But wut if he never actully awoke and this is all a dream. and at the end of book 7 he is is awokeem.

i really hope this theory is incorrect. and it probaly is.

I only like that kind of thing happening in the Wizard of Oz

i would be extremly dissapointed if that happened... but i doubt JK would take such an easy way out, shes had some fantastic ending plotted for years, or so she says

i hope that dosnt happen jk would think of a better ending or she might make harry die in the end

she's more talented than that ... she is capable of giving us a really unexpcted ending ...

I agree with Ladygrim.

Why on earth would she make the entire Harry Potter phenomenum a "Dream"
xx

.... 🙂

very true ada

well. . .it worked in the wizard of oz, but when they did that. . .it was just one book. . .