Most talented Beatle?

In your opinion, who was the most talented beatle? For me, John lennon. Not only that he wrotte the best songs, also i like more her career after beatles. But Paul Macartney and George Harrison were two genious too. And your opinion?

I agree Lennon was definitely the most talented, intelligent and controversial.

Ringo's gonna win this LOL

He narrated Thomas The Tank Engine furchrisakes!

💃

Actually if you look at all the Beatles solo albums then you will find none of the other ex Beatles wrote as good an album as George Harrisons "All things must pass". Therefore, on an individual level, Georgie boy was the most talented.

Musically, Harrison was obviously the most talented, but lyrically, Lennon was the most talented.

However, Paul worked the most at the songwriting craft while Lennon was more lazy because it came to him so naturally.

Ringo... I'm not even to get into this again

I'm not too big of a Beatle fan so I guess, Lennon 😕

Lennon.

No doubt about it.

Lennon has the cool factor for sure - but Paul was by far the most productive/creative in his day... and (heresy) wrote more classic choons than Mr L

Lennon or Macartney

but thats if i had to pick... because to me their all talented... i love the Beatles jump

It sure is easy to choose who was "the best beatle." But they were the best when they were all together as a group. Choosing only one beatle is too hard because they were all talented in one way or another.

John in my opinion was the most artistic. All of the Beatles had talent, but John was in a way unique. He certainly appreciated art and wasn't too fond of censorship. I say it was John.

Why is Pete Best not on the list?!?!

Because a surprising number of people don't even know there was a drummer before Ringo... I'm guessing the creator of this thread was one of those.

Pete Best wasn't exactly an amazing drummer. To say that his drumming was better than Harrison's guitar work, Lennon's songwriting, or Paul's songwriting is ludicrous

I'm going with Paul McCartney. John Lenons words were always more powerful, yes, but Paul's music was better, in my opinion. Paul's words weren't bad, perce, but John just... Got to you better, I guess. But, I still think Paul was more talented, music wise. Just my two cents.

Originally posted by Darth Revan
Because a surprising number of people don't even know there was a drummer before Ringo... I'm guessing the creator of this thread was one of those.

You are wrong, im know very well that pete best was the frist drummer before ringo in the beatles. But when ringo arrives, they were more popular and suscessuful and the beatles hit started. Their first number one was with ringo, not with best.

Originally posted by bakerboy
You are wrong, im know very well that pete best was the frist drummer before ringo in the beatles. But when ringo arrives, they were more popular and suscessuful and the beatles hit started. Their first number one was with ringo, not with best.

Well if you want to get technical, he wasn't the FIRST Beatles drummer, they had a couple before him also, back to the days when they were the Quarrymen or the Silver Beatles.

But the Beatles could have been popular with anyone at the skins; the drumming is so simple, even Meg White could do it. I think it was on the first album that George Martin overdubbed all of Ringo's drumming because he felt Ringo wasn't good enough.

Macartney brought the optimism
Lennon brought the blues
George brought that signature sound
And Ringo, well he err... narrated Thomas the Tank Engine? Always good

Kate xx

I think the saying goes:

John was the heart
Paul was the brains
George was the soul
and Ringo was the drummer.

and Ringo was the drummer.