Were you sad when Haldir died?

I wished Haldir did something in the 4th age, that way, if PJ killed him, there would be a riot. IMO, Haldir had to die. If he didn't, he would have gone with Theoden and co. He couldn't have left, that would have been weird and mutanous. So, he had to die. Of course, I rather not had the elves there.

Manôkhâu (Melcórë)

Haldir needed to die. 😈
*Kills Haldir*

Moo Cow Super Senior Member

i kinda liked haldir 😬 he was alot better than legolas, i dont like legolas

Manôkhâu (Melcórë)

Movie-Legolas sucked.
Movie-Haldir sucked.
I don't like the look of Glorfindel from the card game.......

Thorondor Love?

I hated his death scene but i liked the way it was done....why does everyone hate Haldir he's one of my fav elves in the books 😕, and i was proper pissed off when he died....😆 i actaully screamed "WHAT THE F**K?" in the cinema 😂 everyone looked at me like i was crazy, i wonder why? 😛

Manôkhâu (Melcórë)

I prefer Rumil to book Haldir........

ladygrim The Grim piratess

ive never seen so many frigging threads for one character

aniron Senior Member

lol I actually didn't recognize who he was until after the film but I was sad just because he was an elf, and also when Theoden says "hail the victorious dead" I A-L-W-A-Y-S think of Haldir.

Darth Sauron Senior Member

well,
I felt sad because he neednt have been there, he chose to be there, to help man, and he died there.
I felt sad because the last images he saw were of his kindred dying, and his people dead infront of him.

But im happy he died there too. If he had lived, he would have had to go to valinor and leave middle earth, knowing he wasnt going to get to enjoy what his friends and companions had died for, If he had lived and stayed, he would have to watch the world fade, have to live with the feeling the earth has been scarred.

He died at helms deep in the films, and i think that was the best fate for him.

ladygrim The Grim piratess

🙁

Who's your favorite Elf?