alien or aliens?

Started by ragesRemorse3 pages

How could anyone? Atleast any self respecting alien fan

I do. Jean Pierre Jeunet's cut of the film, contrary to whatever anyone else says, is a more full, defined version. Besides, it's got the most interesting cast and characters, IMO.

ok i cant even touch your opinion on the final cut. We are obviously on two different mind sets here that cant be enlightened with any knew knowledge on eigther side. However, you think The cast in Ressurection was the most intersting cast out of all the alien movies? this is somthing i had to jump into no matter how far away our perceptions are from each other.

It's like this.

Ripley's clone, No. 8, is in a moral dilemma. She's 1/2 human and 1/2 Alien, so her allegiance is tested here, as Aliens are headed for Earth on an abandoned ship. Her apparent heartwrenching decisions are what would led itself to being the most actual development we have ever seen in Ripley, given she was just gung ho in the other 3 films.

As for the characters;

Ripley/No. 8, who is 1/2 half human and 1/2 Xenomorph, who in turn carries what could be certain doom for Earth in her hybrid creature.

"Call", easily the most interesting android to date.

Ron Perlman's "Johner" character, who is always fun to watch.

"Vreiss" (Dom Pinion from "Amelie" and "City of Lost Children"😉 playing comic relief once again, from his wheelchair.

Michael Wincott as "Elgyn", aka "Top Dollar" from "The Crow". If nothing else, his awesome voice and badass attitude really harken back to that of Corp. Hicks in "Aliens".

Brad Dourif, who thinks he has finally found a way to control the Aliens, when it's apparent he hasn't. I personally think he's great, especially in LOTR.

The "Alien" franchise has always had a back-up cast playing second fiddle to Ripley. I just think that this cast was just as good as that in "Aliens". In addition, I think there was alot more tension in "Resurrection", than there was in "Alien 3" in particular, and quite possibly the original.

booooo

ressurection was boring........cheesy......and quite cliche'd. I swear at points I thought I was watching Critters 4.

i could accept alien 3...any more films after that wouldnt be a good idea

i liked them both i haven't seen the third i love alien ressurection 👆 👽

Dont worry, its not your fault

saying you like alien ressurection is the same thing as saying u like halloween 5

Re: alien or aliens?

Originally posted by dean7879
whats your favourite?
they are both equal in my opinion but if i had to pick then mine would probably have to be the first one because it is more horror

Two different directors (Ridley Scott and James Cameron) make it hard to decide which one is the best. I love both films. But I'm more sided with the original. That's only because I like Ridley Scott's films more than James Cameron. Not taking anything away from James, is just that Scott is one of my favorite filmakers. Still, both films are classics.

Originally posted by dean7879
saying you like alien ressurection is the same thing as saying u like halloween 5

I like "Alien: Resurrection", you like "Rocky 5". We're even.

Personally, Scott and Cameron are even in my book. Both super ingenuitive, and still manage to put out great movies. Although, Ripley has kind of pulled ahead with "Matchstick Men".

yes i like rocky 5, its not bad but it shoudnt of been made
ressurection is bad and shoudnt of been made

Originally posted by dean7879
yes i like rocky 5, its not bad but it shoudnt of been made
ressurection is bad and shoudnt of been made

Agreed. any alien movie with Dan Hedeya and Winona ryder in the cast is just destined for shit.

Originally posted by dean7879
yes i like rocky 5, its not bad but it shoudnt of been made
ressurection is bad and shoudnt of been made

Of course, you proved my point of subjectivity.

the first one is superior in my mind, because they have the guys chest blow out. come one, who saw that shit coming? but the second one is good, the thirds not bad, but the 4th.....hmmmmm, no not good even a little

agreed

/-\ |_ | [ |\|

I love the alien series...but if i had to pick from just the 2 aliens has it

its gotta be aliens - unless you saw alien as soon as it came out, it was so taken off it didnt look original any more

You are all fools! Aliens is so much better than Aliens, despite Alien being a truly fantastic film aswell.