Originally posted by InnerRiseBecause...well...because...if they were off the island, they could have gone to a hospital. Yeah, that's the ticket. ❌ Truth is, you can't know if Alex was born on or off the island just yet. I would presume, however, that she wasn't.
And based on that, how would you deduce that the baby was actually delivered on the island?anata wa wakarimasu ka.....
Originally posted by SmasandianThat is if Juliet's sister was even sick the first time, and Ben didn't just lie.
Yeah, but it still cured Locke, Sun, Juliet's sister.
Originally posted by Darth MacabreI meant to say: "Thats if Juliet's sister was even sick in the first place, and Ben didn't lie about the cancer coming back.
Because...well...because...if they were off the island, they could have gone to a hospital. Yeah, that's the ticket. ❌ Truth is, you can't know if Alex was born on or off the island just yet. I would presume, however, that she wasn't.That is if Juliet's sister was even sick the first time, and Ben didn't just lie.
Sorry for the double post, but...
Originally posted by sorrowPenny has been looking for Desmond all this time; and being that the parachute girl looks Brazilian, I would assume shes in league with the two guys at the end of last season that were speaking Portuguese. Those two guys, as you know, called Penny and woke her up the second the Island appeared on radar due to the "anomaly". Then, using those coordinates, I'm almost fairly certain Penny sent in a rescue team, with that girl being the only one to survive. The reason she has that picture is, of course, to identify Desmond as the man they were looking for. Atleast that's my take on the situation.
hey.. arent you guys curious about the pharachute girl (they say her name is naomi??) ... how come she has desmond picture and penny? and didnt she whisper desmond's name before she passed out.. ? 🤨 what is that all about... 🙄
Holy shit, I totally ****ing forgot about that.......that soo make sense.
Wow, when this show is over, I'm going to wait a couple of years, and then buy the DVD's (assuming thier cheap), and have an Lost marathon for a month.
Even though, the show producers dont answer questions very quickly, atleast the show can be watch more than once because of all the twist and turns.
I'm glad I rented the first season awhile back because I cant belive that I would of missed this show. It's right up my alley. I really really like it.
Originally posted by SmasandianYeah, I thought it made a lot of sense myself. Hopefully I'm close to what the writers had in mind.
Holy shit, I totally ****ing forgot about that.......that soo make sense.
Wow, when this show is over, I'm going to wait a couple of years, and then buy the DVD's (assuming thier cheap), and have an Lost marathon for a month.
Even though, the show producers dont answer questions very quickly, atleast the show can be watch more than once because of all the twist and turns.
I'm glad I rented the first season awhile back because I cant belive that I would of missed this show. It's right up my alley. I really really like it. I like it because I love continuity; I hate having plot errors, or plot holes, or any of the like. I like the fact that they have the story written; past, present, and future. Nothing grinds my gears more than a show changing up someone's backstory just to suit a plot of the day type a thing...like that show Charmed did every other episode.
Originally posted by SmasandianActually, Ben's episode is happening sooner than you may think: May 9th is his flashback episode. Which is, I think, the twentieth episode of the season.
Yeah, exactly, and actually, I would say that the backstories and how they correlate to the island is what really got me hooked.I'm guessing that we have Ben's backstory sooner or later...maybe last episode to finally tell us why the Others are on the island.
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
Penny has been looking for Desmond all this time; and being that the parachute girl looks Brazilian, I would assume shes in league with the two guys at the end of last season that were speaking Portuguese. Those two guys, as you know, called Penny and woke her up the second the Island appeared on radar due to the "anomaly". Then, using those coordinates, I'm almost fairly certain Penny sent in a rescue team, with that girl being the only one to survive. The reason she has that picture is, of course, to identify Desmond as the man they were looking for. Atleast that's my take on the situation.
dude.. you're good.. 😉
Originally posted by Darth Macabre😱
Penny has been looking for Desmond all this time; and being that the parachute girl looks Brazilian, I would assume shes in league with the two guys at the end of last season that were speaking Portuguese. Those two guys, as you know, called Penny and woke her up the second the Island appeared on radar due to the "anomaly". Then, using those coordinates, I'm almost fairly certain Penny sent in a rescue team, with that girl being the only one to survive. The reason she has that picture is, of course, to identify Desmond as the man they were looking for. Atleast that's my take on the situation.
I brought this up some pages ago trying to get some clearification on this b/c I remembered that scene being like the cliff hanger at the end of one of the seasons but I couldn't remember which season and I couldn't remember what they actually did with that cliff hanger if anything.....I guess it's coming into fruition now, but I definitely brought this up recently.
Originally posted by Darth MacabreHey!!glare
Yeah, I thought it made a lot of sense myself. Hopefully I'm close to what the writers had in mind.[B] I like it because I love continuity; I hate having plot errors, or plot holes, or any of the like. I like the fact that they have the story written; past, present, and future. Nothing grinds my gears more than a show changing up someone's backstory just to suit a plot of the day type a thing...like that show Charmed did every other episode.
I happen to have loved Charmed and cried when it ended. 😐
anata wa wakarimasu ka.....
Originally posted by InnerRiseAnd I liked the first four seasons, but it still doesn't change the fact that they are known for massive continuity errors, and plot changes. Like the episode "Desperate Housewitches" where the Source gets brought back from the graveyard: Paige asks the sisters "How did you defeat him last time?" Um...she was there, why does she have to ask her sisters? And even if she doesn't remember how they did it exactly, why does she ask "how did YOU defeat him last time." You see? Charmed ran into their problems because they employed ghost writers; or, in layman's terms, writers who aren't employed by the show permanently and only write scripts which are bought by the show. Not bagging on the show as a whole, but it lacked the continuity that Lost has.
Hey!!glareI happen to have loved Charmed and cried when it ended. 😐
anata wa wakarimasu ka.....
Originally posted by InnerRiseOkay, and? What do you want to take credit for my ideas. Um, okay? Everyone it was actually Powerfulone's idea, and not mine. There, happy?
😱I brought this up some pages ago trying to get some clearification on this b/c I remembered that scene being like the cliff hanger at the end of one of the seasons but I couldn't remember which season and I couldn't remember what they actually did with that cliff hanger if anything.....I guess it's coming into fruition now, but I definitely brought this up recently.
Originally posted by Darth MacabreWow.....didn't mean any offense nor did I try to take credit for what you said.
And I liked the first four seasons, but it still doesn't change the fact that they are known for massive continuity errors, and plot changes. Like the episode "Desperate Housewitches" where the Source gets brought back from the graveyard: Paige asks the sisters "How did you defeat him last time?" Um...she was there, why does she have to ask her sisters? And even if she doesn't remember how they did it exactly, why does she ask "how did YOU defeat him last time." You see? Charmed ran into their problems because they employed ghost writers; or, in layman's terms, writers who aren't employed by the show permanently and only write scripts which are bought by the show. Not bagging on the show as a whole, but it lacked the continuity that Lost has.Okay, and? What do you want to take credit for my ideas. Um, okay? Everyone it was actually Powerfulone's idea, and not mine. There, happy?
Just forget it then Mr. Sensitive.
Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....