Who is the best classic rock band?

Started by natalya7193 pages

yes

The Who and Zeppelin, missing the likes of Kinks, Beatles, Deep Purple, Free, The Small Faces, Creem, Faces, Humble Pie, The Yardbirds just to name a few that deserve a place in a poll like this

I agree, and I'm sorry.

Originally posted by bardock
imo those bands suck its mostly stoner music.

I would slap the shit out of you, if you were in my presence and said some amatuer shit like that.

Originally posted by bardock
imo those bands suck its mostly stoner music
says more about your lack of knowledge than anything else

man im scared

You damn well should be. This music is some of the most brillant stuff ever composed.

Originally posted by Arahael
You damn well should be. This music is some of the most brillant stuff ever composed.

Besides Mozart's stuff

some of it is.queen and the stones kick ass but i wasnt impressed with led or the who

Originally posted by bardock
some of it is.queen and the stones kick ass but i wasnt impressed with led or the who

Why not?

just didnt like their stuff thats all

queen and the smiths(even though there not there)

Why, The Who of course. Quadrophenia is the best album EVER

I could agree with that.

Quadrophenia is to me the who album I like the least beside Face Dances and Its hard

bahaha, The Smiths classic rock?

The Who were sonically, technically and creatively superior to Led Zeppelin. While Zep popularized hard rock, it was The Who were the true masters of the genre while they were around; Moon was a far superior drummer to Bonham. It isn't even close the comparison of even a young Moon (check out My Generation) to even Bonham at the peak of his career.

Page was not very creative in his guitar writing; it has been proven that he has taken old blues standards and without acknowledgement just put them in place to Led Zeppelin songs. Also, he did these sloppily, nothing compared to the great guitarists who wrote the riffs.

As for the singers, while forming the band, Page wanted someone who sounded like Daltry (he actually tried to woo Daltry away from The Who first). So he got Plant.

And Entwhistle was in a class of his own at the time, and arguably even to this day.

Basically, to sum up, Zeppelin was like a band of second rate musicians who stole from old obscure artists while The Who was a band of talented musicians who wrote their own music and had a stage show that was almost unparallelled at the time.

Basically, to sum up, Zeppelin was like a band of second rate musicians who stole from old obscure artists while The Who was a band of talented musicians who wrote their own music and had a stage show that was almost unparallelled at the time.
to call Zepplin a band of second rate musicians kind of says more about your lack of musical knowledge when it comes to musicians than anything else.

voted queen, but i like led zeppelin too 🙂

i think that Queen is the best Classic Rock group.

well, second rate when compared to The Who that is.

Page throws out sloppy notes like it's going out of style, Plant's vocals aren't as good as advertised. Bonham, I'll admit, is probably in the top 3 rock drummers of all time. But John Paul Jones compared to Entwhistle? come on, no contest