Originally posted by Ushgarak
Err, these things were being stated as fact, NOT speculation, so you can cut out that attitude. It is not appropritate to put forwards speculation as fact as Bilb did.
Excuse me? Just because I dont preface EVERY SINGLE POST with, 'this is all speculation, but....' doesnt mean I mean that I pretend to KNOW what is or is not gonna actually happen in this flick. And it is not appropriate to single out individual members as you seem to enjoy doing.
Originally posted by bilb
Excuse me? Just because I dont preface EVERY SINGLE POST with, 'this is all speculation, but....' doesnt mean I mean that I pretend to KNOW what is or is not gonna actually happen in this flick. And it is not appropriate to single out individual members as you seem to enjoy doing.
I'll decide what is appropriate or not, thanks! Your post could easily be interpreted as fact; I was correcting that.
Not official but I'l take it, from T Bone:
- Qui-Gon Jinn does in fact appear in the script and begins to teach Yoda how to die but keep your "consciousness" while on Polis Massa. Yoda tells this to Obi-Wan in time, and also tells him that he will soon begin the same training with Qui-Gon.
BOO YAH!!!!
I hope the rumoured Qui Gon scene isnt in Ep3
all that stuff about love being the answer to ending the darkside makes me wanna puke
its not the idea as its a fact - it happens in JEDI
its just the way imagine it will be played out on screen
and as for Qui-Gons voice in EP2 its just a rehash of the "ANAKIN......ANAKIN.........DROP!!!" scene from TPM
its the same sound clip
and everyone knows(or should) the "NOOOOOO!!!" bit isnt Qui Gon
its a Tusken Raider
The "Anakin Anakin" bit is Qui Gon shouting whereas the "NOOOOOOOOOO" bit is a Tusken Raider !!
The Yoda scene takes place after the Tusken slaughter,its Qui Gon shouting out "Anakin Anakin!!!" THEN it cuts to a tusken obviously about to be beheaded or whatevers reaction....Yoda is getting a bit of everything- Qui Gons reaction,Anakins pain and suffering AND the tusken slaughter ALL AT ONCE much like Obi Wan does when Alderaan gets it...just listen to it again...it aint even the same voice!
So Bilb Qui Gon isnt speaking to Yoda directly thru the force..his shout from beyond the grave isnt meant for the little green dude at all..its in the sentance........."A-N-A-K-I-N....A-N-A-K-I-N!!!!"
Doesnt sound so "silly" now does it.
Cy, that is sooo not right. The 'nooooooo' we hear clearly is a different voice than Neeson's but thats simply due to the fact that they already had a voice track of Liam saying 'Anakin!' from TPM, but had no such recording of the 'nooooooooo'. So they simply used another voice. It is still meant to be Qui Gon speaking. Up to this film, Qui Gon is the only one who has been able to retain his identity after death. And Tuskens in general are not force sensitive, ergo no Tuskens speaking to Yoda.
Originally posted by cylob49
The "Anakin Anakin" bit is Qui Gon shouting whereas the "NOOOOOOOOOO" bit is a Tusken Raider !!
The Yoda scene takes place after the Tusken slaughter,its Qui Gon shouting out "Anakin Anakin!!!" THEN it cuts to a tusken obviously about to be beheaded or whatevers reaction....Yoda is getting a bit of everything- Qui Gons reaction,Anakins pain and suffering AND the tusken slaughter ALL AT ONCE much like Obi Wan does when Alderaan gets it...just listen to it again...it aint even the same voice!
So Bilb Qui Gon isnt speaking to Yoda directly thru the force..his shout from beyond the grave isnt meant for the little green dude at all..its in the sentance........."A-N-A-K-I-N....A-N-A-K-I-N!!!!"
Doesnt sound so "silly" now does it.
It sounds very silly, you silly billy..... its supposed to be qui-gon okeday 😉
well ill stick with my theory
that bit of dialogue has been discussed on every SW forum form the OS to Supershitter and its been mostly about who says the NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! part
its been discussed on this very forum too
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-3588
that NOOOOOOOOOO!! is very harsh and alien like...VERY non human and sounds nothing like the TPM lifted "Anakin Anakin" bit..just listen to it its nothing like Liam Neeson and if its supposed to be a soundalike its fu**ing terrible
like many other SW fans well have to agree to disagree on this one
as for the bit about Tuskens not being able to be heard thru the force...what about the people of Alderaan ...Kenobi felt them "cry out in terror" so why cant Yoda feel a sandperson crying out in terror.