Siege Of Gondor

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didint sauron's army just get to the secound level of Minas Tirith? i've read so in sevral places, I just couldint find my old movie mistake thread, anyway it clearly looks like they are on the third or maybe even the forth level here

Look's like the second level to me 😑

no look there are outher houses, and there are no houses on the first wall

heres another one its just a few secs before the first pic I posted, and now you can clearly see they are above the secound level

PJ probably thought that two floors up wasnt epic enough for his audience
so instead he had them get pretty much to the top

well two levels is nothing realy pj probably just wanted to make the scene more dramatic.

Thats what i said 😛

I agree. Thats probably his reasoning behind it although I can't remember how far they made it in the books right off hand. If PJ did do that it was most likely intentional and not a mistake.

They made two levels in the books 😉

Btw- Welcome wavey

Originally posted by Blackhand
I agree. Thats probably his reasoning behind it although I can't remember how far they made it in the books right off hand. If PJ did do that it was most likely intentional and not a mistake.

Well you have to admit... The book was earlier than the film... right?

or? 😛

lol of course...what does that have to do with anything?

gandalf did say fall back to the second level retreat believe me I've watched it enough.

thats true but watch the pics I posted you can clearly see they are above, if you look closly you can see a múmakill on the fields and his as small as a fingernail down there, witch abously mean they are pretty high up, above the 2nd lkevel if you ask me

I thought minis tirith was a seven teir structure built into the mountain.