Captain America vs Guardian

Who'll win this one?

While Cap is a peak human, faster stronger, possessing a shield that defies physics, and has training out the wazoo, he does not have control over nor draw upon the earth's electro-magnetic fields for power, as does Guardian. All common sense points to guardian. All writers point to Cap, alas.

agreed

Sorry, I should have been more clear. I meant Guardian from DC (Jim Harper). I completely forgot about the one you are referring to.

DC's Guardian is well-trained, has no super-powers and has an indestructible shield.

Oh...hmm. I thought Alpha Flight's Guardian, which made sense since it would be the centurions of Canada and America duking it out....

I'm not well informed enough with DC's Guardian to make a statement. Sorry 🙂

Cap pwns this DC ripoff 😎

Captin America wins is Guardian's shield indestructible either way cap wins

Guardian smokes Cap.

Originally posted by batdude123
Guardian smokes Cap.

❌

Not in anyway shape or form

Originally posted by batdude123
Guardian smokes Cap.

We are talking about Alpha Flight Guardian, right? 😕

Originally posted by batdude123
We are talking about Alpha Flight Guardian, right? 😕

Originally posted by King KAM
it dont matter, aint no stinkin candadian ever takin out da cap (says with a new york accent)

This is DC's Guardian. In that case, Cap pwns his ass.

Originally posted by batdude123
This is DC's Guardian. In that case, Cap pwns his ass.

Yeah its DC Guardian 😉

We all know that Alpha Flight Guardian could take Cap down 😛

Originally posted by Grimm22
Yeah its DC Guardian 😉

We all know that Alpha Flight Guardian could take Cap down 😛

hey im canadian!

If it was classic Guardian, Cadmus' Guardian, I'd say it's a tossup. But current Guadian loses fairly easily.

and alpha flights guard had galactus put on his knees.

Originally posted by Juntai
If it was classic Guardian, Cadmus' Guardian, I'd say it's a tossup. But current Guadian loses fairly easily.

Since I've never seen DC Guardian do ANYTHING impressive, I'm going to say that Cap smokes him.