Poll
47%
53%
Lois beat three Kryptonians and Peter stalemate her in their battle. Homer's powers fluxuates too much (big brother fight at aquarium & drederick tatum fight). Still, even at his best, Homer would get beat by Peter.
Here's the math:
Kryptonian > Homer
3 Kryptonians > 1 Kryptonian
Lois > 3 Kryptonians
Peter = Lois
Peter > 3 Kryptonians
Peter >>> Homer
Peters wins.
Time traveling is out of continuity since it's a Halloween special. And in a lot of those characters were killed, so if you wanna count Halloween specials: Homer would be lying dead thus Peter wins automatically.
LinkaliciousHomer is an athlete in peak form (he was an astronaut )
and....and....He was a freaking robot!He even stopped judgement day at Itchy and Scratchy Land.
He didn't do anything when he was an astronaut, even when he saved the day it really wasn't him - it was THE ROD! Heck, wasn't Barney who was to go into space but then got a sip of beer and turned back to his old self? Homer only became an astronaut by default, he's no athlete.