Cheesecake-Pie or Cake????

Started by Zelda Lestat4 pages

Cheesecake-Pie or Cake????

Personally, I like to say its more of a pie........

yeah more of a pie i mean cake has frosting and cheesecake doesnt

Cheesecake droolio

Cheesecake...that is why they call it that😛

so i would say cake

pie, cake... don't matter. it's made of cheese for f*cks sake. go cheese!!!

Cheesecake! droolio

Yanno - i'll give it up to you USAers, the cheesecake you have over there is streets ahead...

As to the debate - It's a dairy product - so it's a cake. Can you imagine calling a meat pie a cake? no - but can you imagine a cheese pie? yes. therefore it's..um... where was I? Crap... hang on..

I'm hungry. Cheesecake goodness...

lmao.....yea, but its made more like a pie dont you think?

pie...i love pie.... droolio

Pie

I say it's cake...

Mmmm...cheesecake...droolio

PIEEE! PIE PIE PIE!

i choose cheesecake

Originally posted by Zelda Lestat
lmao.....yea, but its made more like a pie dont you think?

OK this is really making me want some cheesecake so I will settle this.

Yes it's made more like a pie - but to define "pie" you have to go back to old french or latin - and we discover that it was anything with a pastry crust or a layer cake!!!

So even PIES can be cakes!

Cake on the other hand is an old Norse word - and it's original meaning was compacted layers, these days - layers of sweet baked goodness : but still applicable to any layered substance (ie Caked with mud...) So although you have a Pie base - it's Caked with cheesey goodness - so therefore a cake.

Cake. Not pie. Cake.

Now I hate you for what you have done to my brain.

cheesecake, must have cheesecake......

((🙁 please dont hate me!!!I'm sorry!))

*hands mr zero super smartypants man award* smartest person on this forum

lmao!!!!

droolioCheesecake is so great

umm, cheesecake.....*starts daydreaming about skipping through a meadow holding hands with a slice of cheesecake.*

*me fantasizes the same thing, but, is holding fork in hand, and is chasing the cheesecake, through a garden full of cheesecake flowers*