Jedi Council Members

Started by captainmidnight4 pages

i agree there. thats were the betrayel kicks in,anakin should be honored that HIS mentor is on the coucil,but instead he gets jealous, i like anakin and all but for this reason alone anakin should fall into a burning ring of fire......

that's sort of the point of Anakin's story, you don't have to agree with him. Just understand him. Anakin sees things in black and white. Anakin sees that he is powerful, that he can do so much for the galaxy, only the Jedi won't let him because they're holding him back. He sees that as shortsighted because its a waste of valuable resources- his resources. He feels that someone so powerful should be put to effective use, make full use of his abilities. Its very nietche. It does make sense, why waste Van Gogh's abilities by making him a house painter? That's how he see's it. Its not wrong, just immature.

I don't even think its immature, I think its (in a twisted way) almost mature that he decides to go with Palpatine, because he (in Anakin's eyes) is the only one that seems to know the score, and could put Anakin's abilities to the limits. So I think in an evil sorta way, its very mature for Skywalker to abandon the Jedi Order, and make a decision on his own that he knows will be instrumental to the ruling of the entire galaxy.

Granted he turns evil and kills billions of people but eh, every war has its casualties lol

a mature decision...dont know about that, just becouse anakin goes to the side thats winning doesnt make the decision a mature one...

Well the dark side isn't winning until he turns. If you had Obi-Wan, Yoda, Mace and Anakin fighting Palpatine at once he wouldn't last a minute.

Anakin didn't choose the more powerful side, he chose the one he thought was right for his potential, and since the Jedi Order kept holding him back, he had to get guidance from the only other person, Sidious.

i see what what your saying its a good point!!!!

I agree, good points NoFate! I kinda felt that way too, but was reluctant to use that it was in fact, as you put it, in a evil sort of way, a mature discision because I didn't think anyone would get the context of the terminology.

Edit

So...again...what are the 12 names (official) of the council members? lol

i dont think anakin picked the dark side because it matched his potential. it was the power aspect. the EASY PATH - no waiting to be old and have command - just take it with force

also - im pretty sure hes not on the council cuz theres a picture of him standing before them,

Originally posted by NoFate007
I personally think Obi-Wan is on the Council right now in the story, cause I've seen a picture where he's sitting in a chair next to the hologram Ki-Adi...as for Anakin, I doubt he's on it, but he might be in the process of consideration, which I think makes more sense, and like stated before, the fact that Kenobi is on the Council and not Anakin could help support Anakin's mood later in the story, by thinking he was looked over once again.

Ohhh, well thats cool, makes sense, since they are the best in the war anyway.

1. Yoda
2. Mace Windu
3. Plo Koon
4. Ki-Adi Mundi
5. Agen Kolar
6. Kit Fisto
7. Obi-Wan Kenobi
8. Anakin Skywalker
9. Saesee Tinn
10-12. Stass Allie/Oppo Rancisis/Adi Gallia/Even Piell/Depa Billaba/Shaak Ti/Pablo-Jill

?

IS Obi1 on the council?

i saw a pic of obi1 sitting in a councils chair,looking a ki-adi mundi via hologram!!!its a finished ep3 shot!!!

does any1 kno if obi1 is indeed a member of the council in ep3?
(pm for pic)

XAM 😮‍💨

Rumour has it he is along with Anakin

Anakin on the coucil!!!!!Already!!!!I thougth hed never make it to the council!

Palpatine supposedly helps Anakin secure a spot on the council. I don't like the idea myself, but maybe Lucas will make it work. Only time will tell I suppose. And I'm positive that Obi-Wan is on the council in Ep3.

oh well obi-wan is ok but anakin...no WAY!!!how can the supreme chancellor be able to convince yoda to put ani on the council?

The Dark Side clouds everything.

Maybe all this people in chair business is just the Jedi having conversations... Anakin sat in a council chair is him having his debate/chat whatever with Yoda. Only issue here (and it's big) is that normally Jedi stand when addressing the council, so unless this is a smaller group of people?

maybe but still!