Silver Surfer Vs. Martian Manhunter, Superman
Surfer wins.
Dr. Strange Vs. Zatanna, Flash, Green Lantern, Captain Marvel
Strange wins.
Hulk Vs. , Hawkman, Hawkgirl, Wonderwoman
Hulk wins
Namor Vs. Aquaman, Batman, Green Arrow
Namor win.
Defenders win. There. See, I can match them up so the Defenders can win as well. 😛
Defenders "all the way?" How?
Zatanna can do nigh anything as long as she says it backwards; Superman, Martian Manhunter, Captain Marvel, and Wonder Woman are true powerhouses; Green Lantern can will his ring to do almost anything.
nders? God, this would be ugly. MM can stalemate Silver Surfer. Wonder Woman can overpower Namor. Superman can stalemate Hulk (I HATE to admit it, but it is probably true). Zatanna can stalemate Dr. Strange.
Zatanna ain't going to stalemate Strange for long. I doubt the Socerrer Supreme is that stupid not to figure out Zatanna's power and weakness lies in her voice. Strange summons the Bands of Cytorrak to bind her mouth & hands & she's out of the fight. Strange pulls the same trick on Superman, Captain Marvel, Green Latern, Flash, and Wonder Woman then most of the JLA would be bounded and out of the fight. Unless anyone here is going to argue that the Bands Of Cyttorak can't even hold them even though it's HELD Galactus.
What will the rest of the JLA do, twiddle their thumbs?
Get there ASS KICKED by Hulk & Namor? 😄 They can do that.
But yes this is kinda one sided even if Defenders do have a chance. And this all depends on how each sided is matched up. However, Strange is above or equal to Dr. Fate and both are above Zantanna. Thing with this fight is the Defenders can wipe out nearly half or more of the JLA if Strange was in bloodlust mode or Surfer was. I doubt most JLAers would be standing after a direct & full blast from either Strange or Surfer. On the other hand, Strange, Surfer, Hulk, and Namor have the durability to stand up to most of the JLA, with the exception of MM or Zatanna (if she says the right word).
Thing is, when the fight starts, I doubt everyone is going to be paired up to someone of their equal statis, which is a benefit for the Defenders. They (Namor & Hulk) have a good chance of surviving long enough for the Defenders to win. Each Defender can take a lot more punishments from the other side then can vice versa.