That's gotta be bulls**t. James Earl Jones is going to or has done the recordings. I've heard in interviews that he said he had like five or ten minutes of dialogue to record. But again, the description is someone's INTERPRETATION of the trailer, he might not have understood what he was hearing, they probably made his voice higher and more robotic, as in ANH, so he thinks its not Jones. He did sound a little different in ANH than in the other two. Maybe this guy just never realized it.
I seriously hope Lucas didn't do anything as stupid as not using James Earl Jones for Vader's voice.......
Whatever makes Anakin's voice sound the way it does would be the same then as later. I'm becoming concerned about this classic villian: first, Lucas lets Hayden wear the suit even though he's not tall enough, now he might be the voice, too?! They're going to push the return of Darth Vader, a globally recognized villian, but he's not going to be the same as before? Why not change the costume while they're at it?
I'm starting to become glad there are no more movies after this because George's sense of story logic is gone......
Originally posted by moonwalker741http://s8.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=812B4D2736CAF061FAD0FD95F4E43EC4
it dosent work, uplaod it again and post the link where its the page where you download it, not the direct link
Sorry, my b.
Originally posted by Cipher
I seriously hope Lucas didn't do anything as stupid as not using James Earl Jones for Vader's voice.......Whatever makes Anakin's voice sound the way it does would be the same then as later. I'm becoming concerned about this classic villian: first, Lucas lets Hayden wear the suit even though he's not tall enough, now he might be the voice, too?! They're going to push the return of Darth Vader, a globally recognized villian, but he's not going to be the same as before? Why not change the costume while they're at it?
I'm starting to become glad there are no more movies after this because George's sense of story logic is gone......
Why are you even questioning if JEJ did the voice for Vader? He even said it himself that he already recorded his lines for the ROTS, why is this even coming up?
Sometimes during production things can change. Lucas makes little changes all the time even up to the point of no return. Lucas could have decided not to use JEJ's recordings and synthisized Haydens voice to sound like a much younger Vader. Why does this sound so far fetched? I think it sounds perfectly logical.
They've already interviewed JEJ. He's goind Vader's voice. His voice has just changed a bit in the last 20 years.
Take C-3P0 for example. If you pay close attention, his voice doesn't sound exactly the way it does in OT as it does in the PT. Although he's a robot, Anthony Danie's voice has changed over the last 20 years. He sounds a bit different between both Sagas.
JEJ did record for EPIII but that does not mean that GL has to use those recordings. He has the power to change his mind. The movies are his and his alone. We are just lucky enough that he is sharing them with us. Ultimately the decision lies with GL. As long as JEJ gets paid for his recordings GL can use them as he sees fit.