Feanor, or Feanaro is Quenya, is not evil. He's just ambicious, and that is not evil. Presonally, I think he was powerful and creative, and although his actions did cause really bad things to happen, they allowed for a very good book to be written.
So, no Feanor, no Silmaril, no wars, no interesting stories, no Silmarillion. And if the Silmarillion didn't exist, now would my character. 😉
Originally posted by Telpy
Feanor, or Feanaro is Quenya, is not evil. He's just ambicious, and that is not evil. Presonally, I think he was powerful and creative, and although his actions did cause really bad things to happen, they allowed for a very good book to be written.So, no Feanor, no Silmaril, no wars, no interesting stories, no Silmarillion. And if the Silmarillion didn't exist, now would my character. 😉
no feanor no book i agree but still feanor is evil because the murders on the house of olwes cant be undon
Originally posted by Telpy
Feanor, or Feanaro is Quenya, is not evil. He's just ambicious, and that is not evil. Presonally, I think he was powerful and creative, and although his actions did cause really bad things to happen, they allowed for a very good book to be written.So, no Feanor, no Silmaril, no wars, no interesting stories, no Silmarillion. And if the Silmarillion didn't exist, now would my character. 😉
silmarilon is much about feanor and noldors but its about many other things. but the noldor story wouldnt exist if feanor never did as he did.
feanor wanted to listen to morgoths lies. feanor still EVIL.
Originally posted by Telpy
Oh wow!
I just have print outs from the internet!
*blushes*
Come to think of it, I've never seen any books on LotR languages in the bookshops.
I can imagine 😛
*is glad to live in a country where these exist*
I don't think there are many of them. And as I said; they're pretty good. From the internet doesn't have to be less good though 😉 (As long as it's not the Grey Company site...)
🤣
Originally posted by Draugwen
No, Feanor is not evil. He may have chosen the wrong path, but he was not truly evil. He's on the edge though.
(It's a reason why I like him so much... I have a weak spot for these good/evil-edge persons 😛)
it seems to me that feanor doesn't regret the blodbath (im maybe wrong 😕 ). thats why i think feanor is evil.
Yeah, you're maybe wrong 😉 The Silm wasn't all too specific about it, but then, it wasn't very often where feelings were concerned it seems to me... 😛 And no one really knows about it I think, but then I haven't read a lot off additional book material where it could possibly have been stated, and my memories of the Silm are a bit dim... so I think my perception is a personal one as well as yours 😉
It's one of these uncertain things that so much inspire fanfiction 😛
His wrong path was one, the one he chose by swearing the oath, and he kept to it until his death (which wasn't really very long after... he didn't even have all that much *time* to regret. Except of course in Mandos' Halls, which we don't know anything about... but then the latest I personally am sure he did) I *do* defend Fëanor a lot, don't I? 😛