Hi! I’m another Madelyne-obsessive who’s just discovered KMC Forums and this thread. Indulge me while I do a long catching-up post.
Originally posted by RoguePw25
… I thought it was a really interesting storyline but I always wondered why Scott married her? It seemed to me like the only reason was that she looked like Jean.
Originally posted by Paptimus
You are correct. Direct quote from Scott himself:"I married her (Madelyne) because she looked, felt, smelled like you. My senses told me she was you... even as my mind told me it couldn't be." - Cyclops, to Jean Grey, X-Factor #38
That’s the retconned version. Here’s what Scott said at Jean Grey’s cenotaph in Uncanny #275 (quoted from memory):
“I loved you, Jean. I love Madelyne. I’m glad she’s not you.”
QUOTE=2674774]Originally posted by Paptimus
Quote from X-Man #7:
Nate: Madelyne, I... I'm not real good with sayin' stuff... but ever since... I don't know... you make me... smile.
Madelyne: I know. There's something... special... between us, isn't there?[/QUOTE]
Yes. Friendship can be very special.
I wish they’d developed editor Glenn Greenberg’s concept of the Maddie-Nate relationship as part gadfly, part big sister, part demon on his shoulder.
Originally posted by Paptimus
It's an interesting query as to which character received worse treatment, Madelyne or Psylocke.
At least Psylocke wasn't turned into an infanticidal madwoman. 😠
Originally posted by Paptimus
Inferno was more or less a hastily-cobbled together attempt to get Maddie out of the way.…
Louise Simonson could easily have let the realization of her baby’s peril jolt Madelyne back to sanity. Then she could have died heroically saving him; or she could have survived, divorced Scott, and taken custody of Nathan Christopher, leaving Scott free to marry Jean. (That would also have solved the problem of aging a child without aging the parent.)
But I guess they felt they had to vilify Maddie to vindicate Scott. Had Inferno been written after the decanonization of “Saint Scott,” Maddie might have fared better.
Originally posted by Emtrexx
… I wonder if Scott ever thought about Madelyne after she died. (I haven't read the whole X-Factor series, but I heard there was an issue in which they cremated Madelyne, so he might have)
Originally posted by Paptimus
I can only speak from the issues I have read, and maybe I missed one where he pours his heart out in grief, but …
You didn’t miss much, and Scott didn’t grieve much. X-Factor #40 showed the team walking away from Madelyne’s funeral. Scott (or was it Hank?) wondered how they’d explain to little Nathan Christopher that they saved the world but couldn’t save his mother.
Scott’s epitaph for his first wife was “Maddie was a lie!” spoken in Cable #6. He also said that the baby should have been his and Jean’s. At the end of Cable #8 Cable asked Scott to “tell me …about my mother.” We never did learn exactly what Scott told his son. However, in Uncanny #310 Cable berated Scott for having “dumped” him in the future, but said nothing about Scott’s having dumped him and his mother in Alaska.
At the end of Cable #44, Scott asked Nathan, "Is there any thing that can be done for her (Madelyne)?" Cable replied, "Only what we do for each other. A hand offered in friendship...or a strong set of shoulders to lean on." Of course, Scott never lifted a finger to offer Maddie that hand or that shoulder.
I’m glad “Madelyne’s” appearance in X-Men: The End doesn’t preclude her reappearance in 616 continuity. Heck, even some show of sincere remorse on Scott’s part for how he treated her would be a victory. So would having someone speak for Madelyne as Beast spoke for Jean in New X-Men #156: “You were married to her, Scott. Which implies certain commitments.” Whether Madelyne was Jean’s clone is irrelevant. What matters is that she was Scott’s wife, and a real person whatever her genesis.