I dont really make my decision based on style.. I mostly decide whether I dislike it by :
- If it looks traced
- If it wasnt freehand
- Half-assed ( aka the "Let me draw a stickman and post it to be an idiot" syndrome )
Other than that, I dont base my decision upon the talent/ skill-level of the individual.. if you honestly draw stick men and I see stuff that I like in it you'll get my approval.