Whos annoyed? SPOILER

Originally posted by Thorondor
Just because you became a fan after the movies came out doesn't make you an un-true fan....that's saying that every person who is born after the films and become fans are untrue fans yes?

bullshit 🙄

i don't, but as usual, i'm also very confused

Originally posted by DanielLB
y does no1 ever get wat im trying to say? doesnt matter know anyway....u all seem to hatre me now!

Explain it then.

your "txt" talk isn't helping your appeal 😛

Well, I like the movies, I used to worship PJ, and I'm gonna watch them once a month. But I really think that the epilogue added more of a conclusion for me.

And get off the fact that Daniel is trying to define true fans. You aren't the king of the world either, Thorondor.

Did i say i was?

no hate in the thread!!!

you can't define a 'true fan' because there aren't set standards of what a 'true fan' is...oy vay, now you've got me going

as i said before...no hate

Originally posted by Thorondor
Explain it then.

your "txt" talk isn't helping your appeal 😛

hey bra i dont hate you, and i got what you were trying to say. 😄 😄 😄

Reading the books certainly helps with filling in the blanks that Jackson and his crew left for us. The movie still makes sense but there is a thrill with discovering each new scene in the extended version, even if we read all the spoilers first. Tolkien doesn't leave much to the imagination. I have never read a novel that so finely documented the life of each character to their end; either death or their crossing to the West. It would be nice to see the scouring of the Shire and Saruman's last black works this December, but I will be able to imagine it well enough without the genius of Jackson. I'm more concerned with whether or not we will be able to see his production of 'The Hobbit.'