Vader voice discussion

Originally posted by Red Superfly
Yeah, Lucas gives us the fights we couldn't give a flying f**k about and denies us mech Vader doing damage.

What a jip.

I can see the fights happening, but I doubt we need to have a Kashyyk battle. Don't get me wrong, I think it'll be awesome on screen, and might be one of the coolest parts of the film, but it just seems to me like its unnecessary, seeing as we have a space battle that involves 2 duels, Mace and others vs Sidious and Anakin, Anakin vs Obi-Wan, Obi-Wan vs Grievous, Yoda vs Sidious, a speeder chase, Grievous and Obi-Wan chase, Obi-Wan vs Commander Cody, and all the separate Clone Wars battles that are gonna be quick but still.

"Bring it on! i prefer a straight fight."

This just leads me to believe Lucas has no organisational skills whatsoever.

EVerything ROTS could have been made into a trilogy. Screw Episodes 1 and 2, he could have just made Episode 3 into 3 movies. There's plenty of materila to go around. We could still have Vader kicking arse, Jedi kicking arse, and more time for actual story.

The sheer vastness of STUFF thats in ROTS just makes me angry over the time wasting in Episode 1. The war was a dummy war, the battles could have been cut and nobody would care. The only things of worth were the pod race and the final battle.

The OT was consistent. Evenly spaced out timeline. Bit of action here, some story there, all cut together with mastery and it all FLOWS perfectly.

The PT, on the other hand, jumps around all over the place. Episode 1 has boring time wasting bits (Most of the tatooine crap) and Episode 2 did too (Anakin and Padme "romancing"😉. And now in ROTS it's action action action action. It judders, sputters, comes to a complete halt, gets going again, stalls, has to be given mouth-tomouth when Yoda starts fighting, and then finally get's off the starting grid at Episode 3 going "oh crap oh crap" and throws everything it can at us in an attempt to make up for it's previous failure.

Oh well, we can just look forward to Episode 3, which is looking like movie we were hoping Episode 1 was gonna be in terms of delievrring expectations.

And there's nothing wrong with Vader's voice, thank God.

um.........good point😉

I agree. It is a good point

Hey Red Leader😉 i tried to search for scramba's original link to BTH 56, but its down, so ur best bet is to PM him for it, but i gotta say it the worst BTH ever IMHO🙁

Thanks Stunrun.

rigghhhhhtttttt

Ummm all the episodes are pretty consistant, there is action at the begining, story development, action in the middle, story development, action at the end. I assume that ep III would be the same format.
We had to see epI to understand how palps comes into power.
epII they have to show the romance otherwise it would be stupid when they get married and have the twins, it tends to be only 2 minute clips of the romance and then you are right back into the story.

Originally posted by maul1
Ummm all the episodes are pretty consistant, there is action at the begining, story development, action in the middle, story development, action at the end. I assume that ep III would be the same format.
We had to see epI to understand how palps comes into power.
epII they have to show the romance otherwise it would be stupid when they get married and have the twins, it tends to be only 2 minute clips of the romance and then you are right back into the story.

You just don't get the point. You don't understand why it fails as a narrative. Ep1 was not needed at all.

As far as story goes - the romance never truly kicked off until Ep2 anyway, Ep1 could be deleted and it would have no effect on the matter.

Same goes for Palpatines claim of power. He was a Senator in Episode 1, but we didn't need to see him BECOME one. Same goes for Episode 2, we didn't need to see him become Chancellor.

And you cannot say the plot is consistent. What are you smoking?

u needed Episode 1 also to show ObiWan as young and reckless, and understand why he isnt able to teach anakin

You don't really need teh prequels at all. They exist only as setup for teh OT, which could have been handeled beautifully by EU.

it also shows how anakin wasonce the epitimy(is that hoe you spell that?lol) of goodness, and how something as wonderful as the connection between him and his mom, could start him down the dark path. All about situation manipulation. In contrast to how Han Solo is a dirty, lying, theif, and everything else....but he turns out to be quite a help to a good cause.

This thread has effectively been fu><0r3d.

Good job.

corn

LOL how did this thread go from Vader's voice discussion to the PT!? 😕

well you get caught up in the moment and talk about whats being said....sorry........

Well i was pretty much apart of the problem lol. I went of subject briefly with Red Leader😛

it happens man, no biggie....we all do it at some point......but uh.....yea...vaders voice is cool...... 😄

i agree the new voice is awesome , different yes but definetly in a good way

Originally posted by NateDawgNT
u needed Episode 1 also to show ObiWan as young and reckless, and understand why he isnt able to teach anakin

He's not reckless though. Watch the movie.