King Thor vs Thanos

Started by shokosugi15 pages

Thanos with PowerGem > RKT > Odin >> Thanos

Originally posted by shokosugi
Thanos with PowerGem > RKT > Odin >> Thanos

Interestingly enough, I buy this.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Interestingly enough, I buy this.

And this is why I mock you uhuh

Even with the power gem Thanos was affected by Masterson Thor and many others.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
And this is why I mock you uhuh

Even with the power gem Thanos was affected by Masterson Thor and many others.


I know. If you go purely by Thanos' showing in IG 4 and purely by RKT's showing in Thor 84-5 (?), Thor's gonna win this.

Doesn't make much sense though. Even prior to Death's upgrade he handled the real Thor and Thing simultaneously without an issue. And after the IG saga he went 10 rounds with Odin (without an upgrade to his Thanos Quest self.) And before that showing he was tanking Drax's and Surfer's blasts to no effect. So....**** Starlin.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Interestingly enough, I buy this.

You agree with shokosugi. Automatic FAIL.

Originally posted by Naija boy
You agree with shokosugi. Automatic FAIL.

Pfft, I only buy it if you go by the peak of what each character's displayed. 😛 Really, I don't think Odin >> Thanos. But if you go by what they've done, Thanos has never reignited dead galaxies with backlashes of his power or fought simultaneously on every plane of existence. So meh.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Pfft, I only buy it if you go by the peak of what each character's displayed. 😛 Really, I don't think Odin >> Thanos. But if you go by what they've done, Thanos has never reignited dead galaxies with backlashes of his power or fought simultaneously on every plane of existence. So meh.

Heh. You are already infected. this post reeks of fail.uhuh

*sobs*

Originally posted by celestialdemon
We've seen lots of what the Power Cosmic can do, so if Supes had it, then we can logically use PC feats for him. We've also seen what Thanos w/PG is capable of, and there was nothing shown that he would be capable of beating a skyfather.
How wasn't there? He easily destroyed a team of top tiers. He toyed with them.

Originally posted by celestialdemon
An imprisonment that was strong enough to hold Thor w/PG had virtually no effect on Odin.

So when it's against Thanos, it's the writers building drama. But when it favors Thanos, and the writers suddenly forget the majority of Odin's already established power level, that's all Thanos. 🙄

I know the difference. You just claimed a PG user has only been stopped once (by Thanos of course). I showed you otherwise, and Drax was tapping into it enough to make himself physically unbeatable.Odin saluted him during the fight when he mistakenly thought he won. You can't even prove Odin can defeat Thanos. You also seem to be entirely ignorant of the power gem and it's abilities.

Again, Odin is a warrior of honor, so a salute is not abnormal. Odin was on the winning side of that fight the entire time and was never in any danger of losing. You just refuse to see that.

I've read every appearance of the PG. I just choose to go by what it's actually shown on panel rather than its implied abilities that have never been proven.

Tyrant was still hurt, which proves just how bias you are with your claim that he never was. Whether he was powered up or not doesn't change that.

Even with his mighty power up, Tyrant's amped up counter attack was a scratch to the finger. No wonder Galactus was afraid. Nothing hurts more than a paper cut. [/B][/QUOTE] Yes, but if you read the comic you'd know that Thor was continually gaining more power and strength. Odin cannot. Thor had unlimited potential while Odin does not.

Odin didn't beat Thanos. Thanos beat the heroes. End of story.

Prove Drax was tapping into it. If you cannot show me a scan of him doing so it's speculation. It isn't automatic. So, unless you can prove it quite speculating.

Odin was winning, but he doesn't salute all the time. He saluted Thanos showing his admiration for him. He didn't salute the Surfer did he? Thanos also wasn't defeated.

Thanos didn't lose to Odin he was losing. The pg amps his abilities. How don't you get this?

He was hurt, sure. It also empowered him further. Galactus abandoned the tactic because it wouldn't have worked.

Galactus was on the ground bleeding and at Tyrant's mercy. Tyrant won their second encounter.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Warlock w/ PG against a prepped and Talisman'd Classic Strange.
Thanos w/ PG against an Elder of the Universe.
Thanos w/ PG against most of Marvel Earth's heroes (plus Dr. Doom) in IG 4.
Thor w/ PG against BRB, Surfer, Classic Strange, and the Infinity Watch at the same time. 😬
Champion without the PG getting KO'd by Drax in one hit and stomped by She-Hulk...to with it going toe-to-toe with Thanos, beating BRB, Gladiator, Surfer, Hulk, Classic Thor, Wonder Man, Sasquatch, etc...

Yeah.

why does everyone bring up the ig4 thing as proof of the power gem's powers? ig is > all if the infinity gems individually.

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
why does everyone bring up the ig4 thing as proof of the power gem's powers? ig is > all if the infinity gems individually.

He was basically only using the Power Gem's abilities for that.

Also, that's the version the OP mentions.

Originally posted by quanchi112
How wasn't there? He easily destroyed a team of top tiers. He toyed with them.

He was also getting hurt by them. And beating a group of top tiers is nothing compared to a skyfather who has had universe-shaking battles and has teleported the entire human race to another dimension with ease.

Originally posted by quanchi112

Yes, but if you read the comic you'd know that Thor was continually gaining more power and strength. Odin cannot. Thor had unlimited potential while Odin does not.

Thor had unlimited potential, but he was stopped before he reached that level. Thanos won't start off with unlimited power, either. And RKT starts off at a higher level than Odin did.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Odin didn't beat Thanos. Thanos beat the heroes. End of story.

Which means absolutely nothing. Thanos didn't even scratch Odin. It was no contest

Originally posted by quanchi112
Prove Drax was tapping into it. If you cannot show me a scan of him doing so it's speculation. It isn't automatic. So, unless you can prove it quite speculating.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Odin was winning, but he doesn't salute all the time. He saluted Thanos showing his admiration for him. He didn't salute the Surfer did he? Thanos also wasn't defeated.

Why would he salute Surfer. He folded like a lawn chair after one shot.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thanos didn't lose to Odin he was losing. The pg amps his abilities. How don't you get this?

I get it. What you are failing to get it is you assume an amp of his abilities will automatically allow him to defeat an opponent he originally stood no chance at beating. And you believe this without any proof whatsoever as to this amp putting him above skyfather level.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He was hurt, sure. It also empowered him further. Galactus abandoned the tactic because it wouldn't have worked.

Galactus was on the ground bleeding and at Tyrant's mercy. Tyrant won their second encounter.

Galactus is a being on par with the abstracts. What being on his level do you know has only one kind of attack? And when have you even known Galactus, with as huge of an ego as he does, getting desperate after one attack?

Galactus was on the ground bleeding AFTER his power was drained.

didnt they already fight? i found these scans so idk where there from

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
didnt they already fight? i found these scans so idk where there from

You don't know where they are from?

Oh god there is sooooo much fail there....

Colossus....thats masterson thor against PG thanos in infinity Gauntlet facepalm

And that wasn't really a fight.Thor knocked thanos down.Then thanos proceeded to turn him to glass. Fights that last 3 panels shouldn't be counted...

Originally posted by celestialdemon
Thor had unlimited potential, but he was stopped before he reached that level. Thanos won't start off with unlimited power, either. And RKT starts off at a higher level than Odin did.

Which means absolutely nothing. Thanos didn't even scratch Odin. It was no contest

Why would he salute Surfer. He folded like a lawn chair after one shot.

I get it. What you are failing to get it is you assume an amp of his abilities will automatically allow him to defeat an opponent he originally stood no chance at beating. And you believe this without any proof whatsoever as to this amp putting him above skyfather level.

Galactus is a being on par with the abstracts. What being on his level do you know has only one kind of attack? And when have you even known Galactus, with as huge of an ego as he does, getting desperate after one attack?

Galactus was on the ground bleeding AFTER his power was drained.

Thanoso can't be beaten though and his knowledge of the gems means he will start off far beyond Thor right out of the gate.

No, Odin respected him and didn't beat Thanos who didn't even go all out.

The scan doesn't work.

You get it that Thanos is already in Odin's league and with the power gem Odin and Thor have no chance.

Speculation Thanos stood no chance against Odin.

Yes, because Galactus' attack backfired. Tyrant was pounding him.