Is LotR the best movie you ever saw?

To me, it is. 🙄

No
hideing_behind_computer ... I liked Matrix1 better bag

tomato

... but apart from that they are 😛

sorry I cant link to any other threads with the same topic - they've all been closed 😐

😒

hard one! um Ben Hur wich I doubt any of you have seen or Spartacus, or Braveheart, The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly, Rocky, Masada, Jaws, The Ten Commandments, all of these and some others are just as good as LOTR! but when EE comes I belive it'l be just a little bit just a little bit better then the rest but perhaps not, I've not seen it yet so time will tell!

for me lotr is my fav

yeah, sure

well, I like the Star Wars trilogy 🙂 but LoTR's great......

...the greatest flaw is the movies are waaaaaaaay too long, I don't have the mental stamina to watch all three in a row.

If you'd watch all three of the extended editions in a row, it would prolly be 10+ hours of movie-watching! Can it be done??

no no no if they would have been shorter it would not have been good for the story I say that their lenght is a minimum for the story

yeah, they actually left alot out of the movies that I would have liked to see. Some of the stuff that wasn't shown that I would have very much liked to see was the hobbits' adventures in the old the Old Forest, meeting Tom Bombadil, and their close call among the Barrow-downs (from FoTR). But most of all I would have liked to see the Scouring of the Shire at the end of RoTK. But oh well, the movies are long, but they need to be long to tell the whole story!

ya alot of stuff and the arriving of the men of Gondor not from Minas Tirith, Imrahil, and knights, Forlong, and I would have loved to seee Beregond and someother stuff from gondor, Radgast, Dear Tom.B,

yeah, it would have been cool if Radagast made an on-screen appearance!

Those movies are there to enjoy life in Middle-earth and to give a taste of the books. If people want to learn more about the book, or they never heard of it, those movies are a temptation

Eternal Sushine of the Spotless Mind.🙂

But the LOTR was my favorite movie for many many years😐

yes...

i never include it in my top 10 or whatever because it's not fair to compare a movie that has like 12hrs to tell a story, where as most have only 1and 1/2 hrs to 2hrs to tell a story...

but they are my favorite thing in it's existance...

I have to admit that the LOTR is a fantastic movie and surely history will remember this one, just like they did with Star Wars.
But this is a difficult question, I wanted to choose Star Wars, but I'm not completely sure because I think Texas Chainsaw Massacre is also a cool movie.
So I let this question open, but if I realy had to choose, I would probably choose Star Wars...

LOTR

yeh all three of them r amazing

Star wars is amazing, but I didn't see anything special in Chainsaw massacre. I didn't see it until the end.

Well, wat you expect to see in Texas??
I didn't see either something special in Halloween, still it is a good movie.
Sometimes people just love to see others suffer...