If you were given a chance to live on Arda, where would live?

Started by Mandos3 pages

If you were given a chance to live on Arda, where would live?

I would surely choose Gondolin, with its white wall, in a middle of a valley surrounded by hight moutains, defended by the eagles. What a paradise it would be... well, until the Balrogs came to destroy it of course.

Good choice, would pick the same 😄

But in the third age e.g..... I would take my rest in the Shire hehe 🙂

Welcome to KMC, btw 😄

My favourite location also used to be Gondolin for a long time... then it was Mordor... now it's I think Númenor, that must have been wonderful, though they had so little woodland and it was probably way too hot there 🙄
but I love the atmosphere of the texts taking place in Númenor, it must've been quite an impressive place, the mixture of elvish and mortal culture...

Btw
There are already some threads like that - please use the search function before you start a new topic 🙂

Here some of the similar topics:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=298359
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=3601
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=299793

The Crissaegrim 🙂

i don't know which of the 100 threads i posted in so i'll just answer again...

Lammoth.

In MORDOR! Next to the Mountain of FIRE! MUAHAHAHA!

No, but seriously I would like to live in Lothlorien.

Mordor would be my vacation home! 😄

I'm sorry if I create threads with similar topics as the other ones. I'm new, but I'll get used to it. I'll search before making. Tx for the tip Exabyte

Minas Tirith or Dol Amroth 😄

or maybe also Pelagir

Minas Tirith reminds me of America, so no.
Rohan reminds me of Britain- so no.
Mordor reminds me of America- so no
Isengard reminds me of Britain- so no
Numenor remings me of France, and im afriad of drowning- so no
Lothlorien reminds me of being really bored- why would anybody spend thousands of years with trees?
The Shire- Put it this way, Gandalf is the most exciting person they know- definately no.
Moria- Is dark, only light would be from fire most probably- I would get migranes from the constant flickering. No
Gondolin- Ok, its white, your not allowed to leave and nobody can think 'wow, he lives in Gondolin, he must be rich or cool or even both, lets sleep with him' because nombody knows gondolin exists, or at least they dont know where it is or who lives there. No
Valinor- If i want to live in a dictatorsip i will move to North Korea. If i want to be forced into a religion i will move to Israel. No
Mirkwood- Legolas lives there, N'uff said. No
The River Town From The Hobbit- Cant be that good as i cant remember the name. Also, the locals dialogue in the book is terrible and boring. No
Tol Elessea- If i wanted to live on an island at sea, i would go to Numenor, and as i already said... No
Minas Ithil- oooh, i wouldnt mind living here, can i see the property now? what? theres nine undead kings of men there? well, dont they live room-mates? What do you mean no? Its the tower of the moon, i love the moon! What...tower of sorce...ry? Not a wise name change, who decided on that one? Sauron? Why him? He owns the place? Oh, so he only rents it out? Well, i dont want to live in anywhere nine undead people are, im going to take a pass.
tol sirion- What, he owns this too? Jesus!
Osgiliath- ooh, view overlooking mountains, Gondor and a nice river! Oh but wait, small print says 'Never rebuilt after war of ring' Damn!

I give up! Im not moving! Damn these properties!

hysterical

Its a toss up for me. Either Minas Tirith or Rivendell. Or maybe the Shire lol...I've often fancied life in Numenor *sp as well. So many wonderful places to choose from.

Oh, i forgot about rivendell 😊
But with an agent in charge, it cant be all too good

😄 Good way to put it. But I still think Gondolin would be the most fun place to live, at least better than the Shire.

I would chose Mordor, I have to say that the best part of the movies were the parts in Mordor... 🤣

you would live with those orcs that sleep in their shit, and eat raw meat and breath in ash all day long??? I doubt you would

Darth Sauron... you have too much energy...
i hope you use it constuctivley outside these forums, or at the very least exhaust yourself here so you are physically unable to create mishcieve in the real world...

that being said...

i should explain my reasons for choosing LAMMOTH (AKA 'Great Echo'😉.
it was the place where Ungoliant (Shelobs Mother - and a hundered times bigger) attacked Melkor (AKA Morgoth, Saurons Master - for those who don't read), who let out a scream so loud it reshaped the cliff walls and surrounding mountains so that his scream could be heard still echoing for years to come in that area... and even after how ever many decades it took to fade out, you could still go up to a high point their and yell on top of your voice only to have the echo of Melkors voice return...

cool huh...

plus there wwas the whole thing with the army of balrogs running up and beating the crap out of ungoliant chasing her away until she was forced to consume herself to death...

An orc shouldn't have to be a problem, o.k. probably they will torture me down there because I'm an human, but what is an Orc compared with Sauron??? I would be fearing him not the Orcs....

I dont think sauron would even bother that you would be there, he would let his slave masters on you and would think being raped by a 1000 men would be paradise

My favourite place is Lothlorien, and so I guess that would be the place I'd love to live! 🙂