Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
With Screamo I just think if you're gonna have lyrics that you are trying to put across as intellectual, at least sing them. Don't come out sounding like a Jack Russel terrier with a throat infection. The music itself (which is what matters) just seems like....random to me. The guitars, drums and bass don't ever impress me at all, from a musican standpoint because I play drums and guitar myself. Or from a listener standpoint.
Most screamo bands have a lot of clean vox as well, and quite a few have two vocalists, one to sing and one to scream.
It's not random, just unpredictable. Thats what first attracted me to screamo. The musicians go almost to the point of mistiming deliberately, which won't appeal to the vast majority of people, but it gives it real edge as Df said, and also it can jump from mellow to super heavy without any warning what so ever. All the conventional rules of rock music are thrown out of the window.
However, the ratio of good emo/screamo bands to shitty ones is like 30/70.