rogue vs supergirl

too me this is a good battle
even match to me

Supergirl. Rogue doesn't have that level of strength and I'm sure Supergirl would find a way to avoid Rogue touching her. Obviously though it could end up either way.

super girl can just fry rogue supergirl is faster stronger has other power that an really kill rogue

Rogue's strong, but not strong enough to trade punches with a kryptonian. Supergirl's not as strong as Superman, but she's pretty close though.

I concur, rogue is powerful no doubt about that, but a kryptonian's a kryptonian.... unless rogue could barrow some kryptonyte from lex luther...

Dude nice avatar. But yeah as much as I hate him he's right. Also change it from Junior Member. One hit and Supergirl has it.

supergirl will fry her from far away, with her heat vision....before rogue gets close enough to use the kryptonyte......supergirl would fry rogue.

Supergirl is way better.

rogue come on cause if super girl annoys her she'll just take over her gloves

yeah i say roge myself, she's got more experience (than the new one anyway) an is pretty much invounerable. besides I think it would be pretty easy for her to touch supergirl if the outcome is in doubt and once she does that the outcome wont be in doubt any longer.

I don't know about ya but I'm going with Rogue sugah!

Originally posted by gautam
supergirl will fry her from far away, with her heat vision....before rogue gets close enough to use the kryptonyte......supergirl would fry rogue.

Depending on which Supergirl version. The current one wouldn't be effected by kryptonite. Only the first incarnation, Kara who was Superman's cousin would be vulnerable; the second Supergirl (Matrix) and the third (Earth bunkin Linda Danvers with Matrix) would not. Regardless, her powers doesn't always work as effectively with "aliens." Impossible Man was able to repel her before she took his powers.

I like both characters, but I see Supergirl winning this one.

hey mainstream that was hillarious what you said laughing

Thanks Muff. Ah do try ta be funny sugah.

Originally posted by jinzin
yeah i say roge myself, she's got more experience (than the new one anyway) an is pretty much invounerable. besides I think it would be pretty easy for her to touch supergirl if the outcome is in doubt and once she does that the outcome wont be in doubt any longer.

i think it would be very hard for rougue to touch supergirl with her super speed and all, she could keep her distance, freeze her with ice breath, and pummel her, or she could just blow her away

Supergirl wins this.

how would supergirl know to avoid rogues touch? she wouldn't... so rogue would probably win when S-girl went in to hit her

This some kinda joke? All rogue has to do is touch her.

Maybe, but who's to say it would work? Rogue's powers don't work too well against some aliens, and on top of that, Supergirl, Like Superman, has a forcefield around her body. Whether Rogue's touch work work or not is unknown, but I seriously doubt it.

And as I've said before, Rogue's no where near strong enough to trade punches with a Kryptonian, a few quick blows, added with super-speed heat beam eyes, Rogue's chances are slim.

worked on juggernaut who has a force field and thor who is alien (sorta) and she absorbed the brood queen who is definately alien