Poll
35%
52%
13%
0%
Gotta be Mario.
Goldeneye and Zelda, and even Perfect dark are easily in my top five all time classic games, but Mario 64 was the first time my jaw literally dropped when I played it.
The way it controlled, it was so new, so revolutionary, and yet within the first five seconds you had masterred it. Sheer brilliance.
Mario 64 was magic.