The Official Fullmetal Alchemist thread

Started by powerfulone1987114 pages

Well going by there previous previews, i don't think it would have given anything away since they're literally like 5 seconds long.
I didn't even notice they didn't give a preview.

And I like how they ended it. Usually when they transition from the cartoon in motion to a faded drawing still shot at the end the show's over and i thought it was but then it had 2 more, one for each character. I liked the affect it had on me by doing that.

is it comprehensible.....

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
people just can't hold their tongue. I mean, it's okay to say you know/think it's a guy, but what you said is a spoiler, even if you didn't give details, b/c obviously not everybody knows exactly what the gender is.
I was about to say let's change topic b/c i knew something like this would come up.

is it comprehensible.....

It's not a spoiler in the least. It has been said in the anime already that hes a guy. Lust has specifically said He while talking about ENVY. So dont you dare go telling me that I can't hold my tongue.

Let's say a a new comer coming into the show, asks if Ed is a guy or a girl. You tell them he's a guy. Now whats the difference between that and what I said?

Now if I told you why he's called envy, that would be a spoiler. But if you think telling someones gender is a spoiler, then your ridiculous.

it should be " then YOU'RE ridiculous".

And b/c you said "you'll find out later in the series", it gave me the impression that you don't find out for sure until "later in the series".

So you can't get that mad.

I can't remember Lust saying "he". I'm not saying you're wrong, just saying I can't recall any of those times.

is it comprehensible.....

you forgot somethhing, we found out who pride is!
is it just me or has rose gotten bigger? and who got her knocked up?

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
it should be " then YOU'RE ridiculous".

And b/c you said "you'll find out later in the series", it gave me the impression that you don't find out for sure until "later in the series".

So you can't get that mad.

I can't remember Lust saying "he". I'm not saying you're wrong, just saying I can't recall any of those times.

is it comprehensible.....

The only reason doubt is in people's mind is because of the voice actor. Envy being male is not even a thing in the real version. If FUNIMATION didn't screw up and have Wendy Powell do the voice you wouldn't have any doubt. It's just the fact that they have a woman do the voice brings controversy to something there shouldn't be to.

Rose was "knocked up" by being gang raped.

And since you say we find out who pride is that tonights episode was not new?

it was new. Maybe fullmetallover missed the other episode.

why didn't you watch the new episode deathmacabre?

is it comprehensible.....

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
it was new. Maybe fullmetallover missed the other episode.

why didn't you watch the new episode deathmacabre?

is it comprehensible.....

Darth Macabre.........I got to change that, I dont even like star wars. lol I'm thinking about Count Camazartis, which happens to be the villain in my novel.

I was out, I tape them while I'm at school but I forgot this week.

Why do you go to school so late?

lol, sorry and i never realized the relationship between "darth" in your name to star wars. And since i'm not a fan, i didn't know that was a character.

The lightsaber fights do nothing for me, I just don't see that as action.

What type of Novel is it? How long you been writing? Are you going to release it? Have anymore? How many pages thus far?

How old are you?

Oh yeah and haven't you seen all of the episodes? Why do you record them?

is it comprehensible.....

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
Why do you go to school so late?

lol, sorry and i never realized the relationship between "darth" in your name to star wars. And since i'm not a fan, i didn't know that was a character.

The lightsaber fights do nothing for me, I just don't see that as action.

What type of Novel is it? How long you been writing? Are you going to release it? Have anymore? How many pages thus far?

How old are you?

Oh yeah and haven't you seen all of the episodes? Why do you record them?

is it comprehensible.....

I mean school as in college. I'm home for semester break right now. So when I say when I'm at school, I mean in my dorm.

lol not a character, just Darth as in Darth Vader.

It's an action/adventure, I have been writing it since my junior year of High school, so 2 years. I do plan on trying to get it published. My English teacher told me to add a little more depth to it before I do though. I have no released anything as of yet, but I did ghost write for my English teacher. She writes children's books, she also owns her own publishing company. I know, I know, that's nothing big, but still.

I have around 1000 pages written so far. But it is a trilogy, so I plan on having each book be around 500 pages each.

I am only 18.

I've seen them all in Japanese, not English.

so you're just writing one big story and then you'll divide it up into 3 books?

Was it enjoyable to watch them in Japanese?

is it comprehensible.....

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
so you're just writing one big story and then you'll divide it up into 3 books?

Was it enjoyable to watch them in Japanese?

is it comprehensible.....

Eh, not quite. I've always imagined specific spots where I would stop the books. So, actually in it's birth it's always been a trilogy. It's just a matter that no time passes between book 1 to book 2. As well as no time passes between book 2 and 3. It just continues within the next book.

Not really, I much rather watch them in English.

And tonight's episode was rather good. It solidifies my thoughts of Kimblee being the best alchemist there is.

has any1 seen the movie for FMA yet?

not many, so let's not talk about it please. We're still looking at the second season.

And Darth, I never really thought about who I thought was the best Alchemist. Why would you say Kimblee. And I watched the rerun of it when it came on a couple hours after again, since i was on the computer and was fully paying attention the first time.

I would say that Teacher seems to be top on my list right now.

is it comprehensible.....

Originally posted by Darth Macabre
Eh, not quite. I've always imagined specific spots where I would stop the books. So, actually in it's birth it's always been a trilogy. It's just a matter that no time passes between book 1 to book 2. As well as no time passes between book 2 and 3. It just continues within the next book.

Not really, I much rather watch them in English.

And tonight's episode was rather good. It solidifies my thoughts of Kimblee being the best alchemist there is.

That's why he's gonna die too.

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
not many, so let's not talk about it please. We're still looking at the second season.

And Darth, I never really thought about who I thought was the best Alchemist. Why would you say Kimblee. And I watched the rerun of it when it came on a couple hours after again, since i was on the computer and was fully paying attention the first time.

I would say that Teacher seems to be top on my list right now.

is it comprehensible.....

Ed's still my baby!

Attention Fullmetal Alchemist Fans.

I am taking the liberty of making The Fullmetal Alchemist Role-playing game. It is in the idea thread in the Role-playing section. I'm looking for large fans of the show, and am wishing greatly for assistance in the development of the storyline.

Thank you.

Originally posted by powerfulone1987
not many, so let's not talk about it please. We're still looking at the second season.

And Darth, I never really thought about who I thought was the best Alchemist. Why would you say Kimblee. And I watched the rerun of it when it came on a couple hours after again, since i was on the computer and was fully paying attention the first time.

I would say that Teacher seems to be top on my list right now.

is it comprehensible.....

I say Kimblee because he put up a rather decent fight against scar. Most people would probably say Flame, but the reason I don't is because he's useless in the rain. He would have been killed against Scar the first time they met if Hawkeye hadn't kicked his legs out and shot at scar.

Well I saw the new episode and was full of awe for like 30 minutes afterwards....it was revealing and full of action plus a suprise ending...cant wait till the new one....no idea if any of the posts were directed to me....so like yeah...i dont care....

Yes Darth! And that's why he's gonna die...Ed put up a decent fight with Scar and he's alive and well!

And I know JLRed! So much happened! To me it looks like Lust will be the next to go...and Rose talked!!!

i dont really care if lust goes next, i dont want wrath or sloth to die yet, they already killed greed 🙁

Originally posted by sailormoon
Yes Darth! And that's why he's gonna die...Ed put up a decent fight with Scar and he's alive and well!

And I know JLRed! So much happened! To me it looks like Lust will be the next to go...and Rose talked!!!

Why do you think Lust is going next? Sure, she's gone out by herself, but she's still not even close to the danger. In my opinion atleast.