Originally posted by powerfulone1987
And at the end of the day Wrath deserves the worse.is it comprehensible.....
For killing a soul-less monster that was going to be killed any way? I'm sorry but Wrath deserves the least of any punishment....He's only killed 1 person, or thing rather, and she deserved to die....The other Homonculi killed innocents all over the place.
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
For killing a soul-less monster that was going to be killed any way? I'm sorry but Wrath deserves the least of any punishment....He's only killed 1 person, or thing rather, and she deserved to die....The other Homonculi killed innocents all over the place.
I know he's not the worse homonculus.
I started off saying how I didn't understand why people were feeling sorry for him. And then I started stating why I didn't.
I'm not saying he's worse than any other homonculus or better. I just happen to be talking about him at the moment b/c of things said by other people.
Point: Wrath is bad and deserves no pity.
is it comprehensible.....
Originally posted by powerfulone1987
This has kind of gotten off track.I know he's not the worse homonculus.
I started off saying how I didn't understand why people were feeling sorry for him. And then I started stating why I didn't.
I'm not saying he's worse than any other homonculus or better. I just happen to be talking about him at the moment b/c of things said by other people.
Point: Wrath is bad and deserves no pity.
is it comprehensible.....
You can't say he was bad, when he did nothing wrong...Name one "bad" thing that he did that had consequences? And killing Lust is not an option for you to say.
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
For killing a soul-less monster that was going to be killed any way? I'm sorry but Wrath deserves the least of any punishment....He's only killed 1 person, or thing rather, and she deserved to die....The other Homonculi killed innocents all over the place.
Hey! Lust is not a monster! It's not any of the humunculi's fault they were created. They think they have identities that they don't have, and it's not fair that they have to live that way. Dante manipulated them. I mean really, what do they really have to do with their lives?
Kill? She's right they think about becoming normal all the time. That's why they want to find the philosopher stone! It's all dante's fault and alphonse and ed's fault. But ed and alphonse did it for a reason so there not guilty. But dante did it to gain power! She lies to them every second telling them if they find the philosopher stone she will make them human. They heard it so many times they know she won't make them human. But they have nothing else to do but...kill.
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
You can't say he was bad, when he did nothing wrong...Name one "bad" thing that he did that had consequences? And killing Lust is not an option for you to say.
And killing anybody is bad and Wrath killed Lust, so I hold that against him. It doesn't matter that it was Lust, he killed and that's that.
is it comprehensible.....
Originally posted by powerfulone1987
All his attemtps at killing Ed and his attemtp to kill Teacher. Doesn't sound good to me.And killing anybody is bad and Wrath killed Lust, so I hold that against him. It doesn't matter that it was Lust, he killed and that's that.
is it comprehensible.....
Attempted murder, and murder are two different things...You can't hold a little boy who knows nothing except hatred accountable to things he has no knowledge of...And when push came to shove, he tried fighting Dante, no matter the reason why, he still tried to fight her.
It's like this....If this was in normal situations he would have tried to physically beat Ed and Teacher, but being that he had powers, it made it look a lot worse then it actuallyw as....He was irresponisble, but he's a kid, and most kids aren't that responsible.
Originally posted by sailormoon
Hey! Lust is not a monster! It's not any of the humunculi's fault they were created. They think they have identities that they don't have, and it's not fair that they have to live that way. Dante manipulated them. I mean really, what do they really have to do with their lives?
Yes, Lust is a monster....Sure, she didn't have anything to do with her creation, but she's still a monster.... By definition she's a monster.
Originally posted by sailormoon
Nuh-uh... 🙄 And even if she is a monster, by definition, you didn't have to put it so meanly "For killing a soul-less monster" that was mean...
Being soulless is what makes her a monster.....There is nothing you can do to defend them....So what they're getting used, because Dante is hanging what they want over their head, but they still kill.....They made the choice that their needs, their wants, are more important then lives....That is a monster, no matter how you look at it.
And mean? Give me a break....Does she have a soul? No. Is she a monster by definition? Yes...Therefore, she's a Soul-less monster.
Originally posted by sailormoon
Yes, but what would you do? Yes, she was evil for killing people, I'm completely with you on that. But, come on, she tried to change her ways right? And yes, I know you will probably say it, her changing her ways is not going to bring those lives back. But, I think even Ed somewhat forgave her.
She was only changing her ways to become human...She knew Dante wouldn't turn her into one, so she chose Ed.
Originally posted by FullMetalLover1
can't we all just get along and watch anime together?
Oh, we're just having a little disagreement! 😛 No one's angry!...well I'm not... By the way love the sig!
Originally posted by Darth Macabre
She was only changing her ways to become human...She knew Dante wouldn't turn her into one, so she chose Ed.
Oh, come on! Couldn't you see the sadness in her face? The pain of having a life that really wasn't valued by anyone? So many memories that weren't really hers at all? I felt sorry for her. Sure, I'm sure she wanted Ed to make her human, but, humonculi really are miserable creatures...and it's not even their faults...doesn't change the fact of the death they've caused...but, don't you feel a little sympathy for them?