Pulp Fiction vs. Reservoir Dogs

Started by tabby9993 pages

didn't the one in the kitchen during the "bonnie situation" read something else, i knew they all held a similar time though

qt

hey lets face it quint fans pulp had more going for it all the way around. Quint finished a movie and was well adjusted after dogs so he could make a masterpiece like pulp fiction. Dogs is still great thought just not a master piece like pulp fiction. That movie has the greatest lines a movie fan can ask for. I loved the example ealier about Jules talking about why he does not eat pi products 😛

reservoir dogs vs. pulp fiction

Lets face it. Both films kick unrivaled ass. Personaly I prefer Reservoir Dogs. It is definately my favorite movie. I can honestly say that with out a problem I can repeat the entire movies dialouge word by word. Even though I feel this strongly about Dogs, I'd have to say (I'll probably kill myself later for saying this) that Pulp fiction is a superior film. Its dialouge and intensity is without question and the following that this film has produced is amazing. So even though I personaly prefer Reservoir Dogs I'll have to go with the majority and vote for Pulp Fiction.

I like PF a tny bit more then RD

Originally posted by Machete_Guy
I like PF a tny bit more then RD

same here
I find it more watchable, but that's just me

I'll proabbly have to watch Pulp fiction again, because I've only seen it once and I've seen Reservoir dogs a million times, there was a point were I prefered Pulp Fiction, but that has passed. By far Reservoir Dogs is my favourite film, not just out of the two but of all time. I love every aspect of that film. Madonna Speech, Cutting off the cop's ear and the artisic vaule of the commode story is incomprehensible. I'll proabbly see pulp fiction again and change my mind but until then RD it is.

Originally posted by Solo
First off, From Dusk Till Dawn wasn't really even Tarantino's film. He just wrote the screenplay and had a small part in the movie. And it wasn't the slightest bit horrible.

yeah, form dusk till dawn was a pretty good film it was pretty funny and had some good action. Also it was directed by Robert Rodriguez.

fxghsfg

Pulp Fiction

Damn it I love both!
Then again I love most things affiliated in any way with QT.

They are both amazing, so, my decision goes to me......

........I MEAN BOTH!!!

you should have added Jackie Brown another GREAT movie

It has to be Reservoir Dogs, the movie that made Tarantino. Pulp Fiction was only alright, he should have cast Michael Madsen instead of John Travolta, but I guess that is neither here nor there.

reservoir dogs is great however pulp fiction is a work of genius. i strongly dis agree with hartigan as i think john travolta was grat as vincent.

just to add to all the talk, dusk till dawn is great even if quentin didnt direct it he made it with his charecter

...I just started watchin QT movies coupla weeks ago...and I Pulp Fiction is a pretty good film too....Im gonna rent it first....its rated R as I saw and says a lotta reasons for it...im not gonna go into that....should it really b rated R or theyre just overreacting again?? cuz in some movies its not even like that and still rated R....so just wondering so my parents would lemme rent it ;D

and I *hear* Pulp Fiction

Originally posted by Elm_Psycho1428
...I just started watchin QT movies coupla weeks ago...and I Pulp Fiction is a pretty good film too....Im gonna rent it first....its rated R as I saw and says a lotta reasons for it...im not gonna go into that....should it really b rated R or theyre just overreacting again?? cuz in some movies its not even like that and still rated R....so just wondering so my parents would lemme rent it ;D

It was going to be NC-17 for awhile.

The only real reason I can think of why it's rated R, is because of:
Strong Language
Drug Content

MPAA overreacted big time with the violence though.

*looks on back of Pulp fiction DVD*

"Strong Graphic Violence"?

All I can think of is:

-

Spoiler:
Vincent Getting shot to hell

-Butch and Wallace getting bloodied up
-"I Shot Marvin in the face" - tons of blood there
-The Hit in the beggining

The only real reason I can think of why it's rated R, is because of:
Strong Language
Drug Content

Let's not forget the 'Rape' and The talk of the Womans Clit.

Reservoir Dogs. Michael Madsen did phenomenal as Mr. Blonde.

Originally posted by Impediment
Reservoir Dogs. Michael Madsen did phenomenal as Mr. Blonde.

Who wasn't phenomenal in their role?

Originally posted by DarkWizard

-
Spoiler:
Vincent Getting shot to hell

-Butch and Wallace getting bloodied up
-"I Shot Marvin in the face" - tons of blood there
-The Hit in the beggining

None of those are actually graphic.