SPOILERS
saw it today. Was pretty awesome, BUT
I think I still think the classic 1933 one was more horrifying and more dramatic. King Kong was bigger (50 feet as opposed to 25 in the new movie), the dinosaurs were scarier, the mood was more tense, nothing felt corny or out of place. Even Jackson himself said his remake wont' be as good as the original.
I think I just like the fact that, despite all the fake-looking clay figures for Kong and the dinosaurs, the way it was shot made it a very scary monster movie. The eeriness was definitely there ...always foggy. Dinosaurs were always lurking around....you see a part of them before they come out and attack. And the background music was definitely fitting...bass....trombones, and very dramatic like a symphony orchestra. Kong's entrance...his closeups...and his savageness was all there. This is because they were making a horror movie when it first came out. It was definitely a B movie classic.
The thing that put me off about the new one was....I dunno...making everything anatomically and politically correct? Kong was definitely a huge GORILLA, who walked on all fours, exhibited all sorts of gorilla behavior. The classic Kong was a humanoid monster. He walked on 2 legs, he wasn't very hairy, and he'll give you nightmares. And the natives. In Jackson's movie, they're depicted as voodoo-practicing, savage ORCS....probably to deter sensitivities towards the original classic where the natives were straight up African Americans who were tribal islanders. The natives in the classic were nicer, they had culture, and they even came out to help when Kong came after Ann. In Jackson's remake, the natives were some freakishly scary monsters themselves who disappeared after Kong took Ann.
As for Kong's attack of NY, in the classic, he was scarier. He bit people, he stepped on (MASHED) people, and he grabbed sleeping beauties out of their rooms and let them plunge to their deaths. You really can't feel sorry for him in the classic until
Spoiler:
the very end when he got shot down by planes
. As for Fay Wray's depiction of Ann Darryl, she never showed any compassion for Kong in the classic. Her role was just endless screaming and being the damsel in distress.
I guess for me, a classic will always remain so, but Jackson's did come pretty close.