Let's do a run down on All the combatants accomplishments/abilities...
Homer Simpson
Stood up to Dredric Tatum for several rounds without getting KO'd..
Has taken Cannonballs and fists to the stomach and absorbed the with minimal damage...
Came close to beating the crap outta of Barts Big Brother....
Survived a 1200 foot fall off of Springfield Gourge...
Has come close to nailing 3 chicks since the his Marriage to Marge...
Hank Hill
Sits around a damb truck and drinks beer with a bunch of Rednecks...
Can barely get it up to give it to his wife peggy....
Peter Griffin
The creator of this show has given him the ability to take just about every annoying characteristic from every other dysfunctional family dad ever shown on television.(Fred Flintstone, Homer Simpson, Archie Bunker, to name a few..)
In addition, the entire show has the ability to to be completely unoriginal and steal the cast from other cartoon shows/sitcoms.
A run down on the cast and the stolen characters they represent is as follows:
Peter Griffin(Cross Between Homer Simpson/Fred Flintstone/Archie Bunker)
Wife(Cross between Marge Simpson/Archie Bunker's Wife)
Daughter(Cross between Lisa Simpson/Thelma from Scooby Doo)
Son(Butthead from Beavis & Butthead)
Baby(The Brain from the cartoon show Pinky and the Brain)
Talking Dog(Dogbert from Dilbert)
Besides being able to fight, Homer Simspon wins based on the originality factor hands down. All he has to do is go for the family jewels and he'll ensure victory...