Originally posted by eggmayo
Metallica. They **were** a great band, but after the Black Album and Master of Puppets, they started going downhill major-league.
Hopefully, Saint Anger is the worst they'll ever get and they come back onto form.
Agreed, tho i thought the soung st anger was quite good the rest was shit tho
Re: music you find overrated
Originally posted by tabby999
what bands do you find overrated? and remember, overrated dosn't nessesaraly mean that a bands bad, it may mean that you think they are given too much appreciation.
my list:tool
deftones
franz ferdinand
either bands are over ratted or underrated, nobody ever rated themto their equality 😬 it just depends on the person
Originally posted by eggmayo
Metallica. They **were** a great band, but after the Black Album and Master of Puppets, they started going downhill major-league.
Hopefully, Saint Anger is the worst they'll ever get and they come back onto form.
Agreed. I LOVE Master of Puppets (my fave Metallica album), but lately...😬 I hope they'll get back to that level.
Yeah but are Metallica over-rated though?
Pretty much anyone who's anyone said St.Anger was tosh. That's not really being over-rated, because not many people liked it, and the reception was just.
Metallica were given credit for the good stuff they did, and people want to see them return to that form. I don't think anyone would say they are over-rated, because nobody really rates them at all these days.
imo I think Metallica aren't under rated or over-rated. I think whatever attention they have recieved has been just. Black album turned heads, St Anger turned heads the other way. Fair cop I say.
That's why I said Razorlight. They are STILL being put on a pedestal and get hyped up even though I think they're a band that sound "different" rather than "good". I hate it when bands are different for the sake of it - what's the point when being different = shit?
They need to look at the likes of Stone Roses to see how a band can be fresh and brilliant.
Originally posted by tabby999
DeathBlow, sorry for not being properly specific way back towards the beginning when talking about Defones inventing, what i ment was their involvement with the forming of NuMetal (with Korn). and your right, they are consistent. consistently shit 😉 wasn't that a cheap shot!
I don't really class them as a nu metal band. They're too smart.
Well anyway, whatever floats your boat homes, i'm not gonna try and force my opinions on you. I've given my argument, and if thats the best you can come up with, nothing more needs to be said.