Originally posted by MatchesMalone
What? Now, that's just plain silly. I don't care how easily Reed should beat Captain America in a logical, well written battle. Captain America is one of Marvel's most popular heroes and he has a huge fan base. There will always be somebody to argue for their favorite hero, no matter who they are facing. If nobody decides to argue for Captain America in this thread, its because his fanboys are getting lazy. Frankly, I'm disappointed in them. They let the good captain down.
You are right. In the comics, PIS would rule and Cap would take it. Reed's powers would suddenly not make him immune to the shield or something. Meanwhile, without PIS, Reed easily takes it.