Cinemaddiction
AmStar 14 Manager
Originally posted by Mando
Minority report, and the first episode of "Firefly" released around the same time. And Joss whedon had been contemplating on the show for a long while. So really nothing was stolen from "Minority Report". Assuming you watched "Firefly" because you sound like you know what you are talking about, Malcom Reynolds Appears to be much like Han solo after first viewing. But if you look into his characters background story, Mal Used to be in the Army, and when seeing all this war, and bad luck. He thought god did not exist. Unlike Han he does not pilot the ship, that is the major difference. One of my favorite Characters 'Jayne' stands out from everyone else in my opinion. And all the other characters are colorful in their own way. Joss Whedon has a great method of character building. He uses grudges and Anger, unlike most of the 'Star Wars' characters use. They tied in Spaghetti western with Sci-fi and made this brand new concept, And I thought the movie was good. Not your average sci-fi which made it all the better.This is all just my opinion of course. I hold no grudges against yours. I'm just expressing how I feel.
That's fine. I just have a differing opinion, and some *hopefully* valid facts and observations.
* The whole "Minority Report" comparison was for effect. The similarities are purely coincidental, aside from the fact they're both female, can predict the future, and end up being the sole character of which the two movies respectively revolve around.
* Reynolds vs Solo - The similarities are uncanny. Did he (Mal) not make mention of Serenity being "his ship" in the movie? Han didn't believe in "hokey religions", either. I mean, the personality traits in both characters were almost identical right down to dialogue and demeanor. Not to mention both their names are 3 letters long....Han...Mal...I mean, I don't care if it's some homage, but I'm calling a spade a spade when it comes to rooting out any originality or depth in these characters. As a sidenote, Han didn't fly the Falcon always either. Lando took over in ESB.
I could go on with the whole relevency of Star Wars references in "Serenity", namely the love/hate relationship between Mal, a ship captain, and Inara, who's the space princess. It only goes to show how truely original the "Firefly" franchise really is. It's so blatantly obvious that there's little originality in Sci Fi on the whole, and that it's how you go about making a name for yourself, using what little shred of ingenuity and creativity left in the genre there is is what matters. Shepherd Book...Obi Wan Kenobi. Jayne..Chewbacca. It goes on and on and on.
"Serenity" isn't so original, afterall. Don't hate it now because I brough out the big guns and shot it down. Original Sci Fi is hard to find, which is why I latched onto and championed "Riddick" when it came out. It was an incredible Sci Fi story. I mean, atleast "Spaceballs" had the decency to come right out and say it was a "Star Wars" parody, where as this isn't much more than a recycling of everything we've ever seen, dumbed down and stripped of the grand scale, making it palpable and seemingly "new" to a new age audience.
River was a great character, and sorely underused. The movie had potential that was never fully realized, and that's my opinion, and I'm stickin' to it.
BTW, "Firefly" was dropped because of poor ratings. That's going to happen when you've got to compete with Stargate, Farscape, Lexx, Star Trek: Voyager, Star Trek: TNG re-runs, The X-Files, and whatever other Sci Fi television shows were running in 2002.