Desperate Housewives

Originally posted by lissa
I just wanna say that even though the mike and Susan thing is repetitive it doesn't make it annoying it mite for sum ppl but maybe thats just because u don't like romance, the writers have obviously done this on purpose, 2 keep on creating cliffhangers. Nobody's cares whether its repetitive or not and it also doesn't make the writers any less brilliant than they already are!!

Everyone's opinion matters, and if you were arguing a point, so be it. But to say things like, "maybe u don't like romance" that's just too much. I never said I didn't like romance. The ever-lasting, every season Mike/Susan/? triangle has gotten really old for me.

Originally posted by InnerRise
Ummm..............NO. Eddie didn't just kill herself over a man. If you hadn't failed to encompass the entire issue and the COMMENTARY that was given when she (attempted suicide) you'd get the reason why.

I wish you had of just come out and said the reason why you think she committed suicide instead of scratching the surface of it. That would have made much more of a debate.

I understand that Eddie had no family, she wanted to feel like she belonged, etc. but it came across that she committed suicide over a man. Even though the situation was probably a lot more, it came across over a man. And I think the writers could have done a better job at making this more clear. Even when her son visited, the primary reason she wanted custody of him, was for a man, to keep Carlos around. So to me, it's not that stretch of an imagination to hypothesis that she killed herself over a man, especially when he breaks up with her and the next scene, she kills herself.

Ummmm nooo.. The writers made it quite clear why Eddie killed herself and it didn't come across that she JUST KILLED HERSELF OVER A MAN. You just fail to GET IT, to UNDERSTAND IT.

It came across just as the writers intended and I GOT IT.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Originally posted by InnerRise
Ummmm nooo.. The writers made it quite clear why Eddie killed herself and it didn't come across that she JUST KILLED HERSELF OVER A MAN. You just fail to GET IT, to UNDERSTAND IT.

It came across just as the writers intended and I GOT IT.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

No again, I didn't "fail" to get anything. Whatever the reason (that you fail to even say yourself) did not come as clearly as you claim. Everyone has an opinion and an interpretation of what happened on the show. If you would like to discuss it, or debate about it, fine, but there is ZERO reason for you to be rude or offensive. And your post is nothing short than being rude (telling me what I didn't get or understand is completely uncalled for). Please refrain from doing things like that, it only encourages fights. 😉

Moving things along, what did you all think about the rest of the season finale? Opinions please?

Actually, if I understood something and you didn't and I state that, that's not being rude. It's telling it like it is so stop being sensitive and get off of your high horse.............."😉"

And yes, everybody is entitled to their own opinion, and my opinion is that you missed the entire reason for Eddie killing herself if your only reasonings lead you to believe she did it solely over a lone man.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

The rude part comes with how you sated it. You have repeated made it known as if what you say is the gospel truth and that's it. And if I missed it, you then had to explain to me WHY I missed it. That's rude. You can't tell a person "why" or "how" they missed something. What's even more disturbing about your posts, is that you never state what those reasons are. You keep telling me that I missed the reason that Edie killed herself, yet, never once have you actually explained why. "She did it because. . . ." This is a discussion forum set up to discuss shows, yet you are not moving anything along. You just keep telling me what I missed and why, and yes, that is rude.

So I as I stated in my previous post, please refrain from doing this.

As I also said in my previous post, let's move on from this and discuss other things about the episode. What did you think about everything else that happened? Was anyone else surprised about Bree returning and with her daughter?

I don't KEEP ON telling you what you missed. You stated something and I clearified why it was appropriate for me to say what I said. I was ready to move on.

So in response to your last post in which you repeated everything you said over again, I'll repeat as well, but in the easy way by doing this:

Originally posted by InnerRise
Actually, if I understood something and you didn't and I state that, that's not being rude. It's telling it like it is so stop being sensitive and get off of your high horse.............."😉"

And yes, everybody is entitled to their own opinion, and my opinion is that you missed the entire reason for Eddie killing herself if your only reasonings lead you to believe she did it solely over a lone man.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Now on to Bree. I wasn't surprised b/c the previews clearly showed that she would be returning for the finale, not to mention interviews that she did on television which she hinted she would return.

And Bree didn't return with her daughter as you put it. Her daughter is with the Nuns until she births her baby so that her mother may pass it by as her own.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Originally posted by InnerRise
I don't KEEP ON telling you what you missed. You stated something and I clearified why it was appropriate for me to say what I said. I was ready to move on.

So in response to your last post in which you repeated everything you said over again, I'll repeat as well, but in the easy way by doing this:

For starters, the only reason I said what I said was because you repeated everything that you said. So the same thing applies to you. But whatever. I felt that your post was rude and asked you not to go on like that again. That's all we need to be clear about.

Lastly, please do not talk about this topic anymore in this thread. If you have any other issues with what I've said to you, contact me via PM, but do NOT continue this in this thread. It's just not fair to the other other members. Thanks.

On to Bree. I wasn't surprised b/c the previews clearly showed that she would be returning for the finale, not to mention interviews that she did on television which she hinted she would return.

And Bree didn't return with her daughter as you put it. Her daughter is with the Nuns until she births her baby so that her mother may pass it by as her own."

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

How is it okay for you, mister self righteous, to continue on with this stupid minuscule matter, but when I post something in my defense basically telling you to STOP OVERREACTING, and to GET OVER YOURSELF b/c you're just TOO SENSITIVE, it gets deleted by you.

I did nothing wrong and it's an ABUSE OF MOD POWERS for you to do that.

If you want to do something like that, delete all of the posts including yours b/c you're keeping it going just as much as I am if not more b/c of your disability to GET OVER IT.

Being rude, as you called it is not something you can act on just b/c you got your feelings hurt.

I said I WASN'T being rude, you thought I was. So what? You're a big boy, get over it and stop editing posts in your favor.

It's ridiculous and juvenile.

If posts were deleted just b/c someone thought they were rude, more than half of KMC would be gone.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

Double Post.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

There's no abuse of powers going on here, InnerRise, just you whining and taking things to far. He asked you to stop the petty debate with him, because it's clear that it's becomming personal and now has nothing to do with the thread. As such, I'd suggest you listen, take it to PMs, as he suggested, if you want to continue such a silly argument. It has no place in the thread. So drop it.

I took nothing too far. HE did (editing someone's post over hurt feelings=taking it too far). It was dropped. You picked it up. Drop it.

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

He's the mod. He has the power and the right to edit posts that he sees as hurtful or detrimental to the forum/thread. Once again, he took nothing to far, he made a judgement call, and the right one, at that.

Hurtful...detrimental? Hilarious.

As I said, I was refuting is accusations of me being rude and hurting his feelings. You don't delete posts b/c of those reasons.

I was talking about the show......he's the one who went off topic first with the whole....."Say it like I want you to say it b/c you're being rude and I don't like it."

It wouldn't have even went this far if he'd stayed on topic and not resorted to abusing his powers b/c he didn't like what I was saying about the show and his perception of it.

It all started with this post:

Originally posted by RoguePw25
No again, I didn't "fail" to get anything. Whatever the reason (that you fail to even say yourself) did not come as clearly as you claim. Everyone has an opinion and an interpretation of what happened on the show. If you would like to discuss it, or debate about it, fine, but there is ZERO reason for you to be rude or offensive. And your post is nothing short than being rude (telling me what I didn't get or understand is completely uncalled for). Please refrain from doing things like that, it only encourages fights. 😉

Moving things along, what did you all think about the rest of the season finale? Opinions please?

And the fact that you agree with him means nothing, being that you're a mod as well.

And just as you stated in your post: "He's the mod. He has the power and the right to......."

That's the mentality the majority of you Moderators have and it's wrong. It doesn't make you right just b/c you can do these kinds of things. It just means that you can do and say what you want without any repercussions, all the while reprimanding everyone else for things such as "BEING RUDE" when that is what's UNCALLED FOR.

I've seen discussions far more heated and crude then this one without a single word, b/c either the member involved was a well liked one, or the Mod in the situation didn't TAKE IT TOO FAR and overstep their boundaries.

Rogue cannot control every aspect of a discussion and if I want to say something such as "I don't agree, you're wrong, I GOT IT and blah blah blah..." that's no reason to come at me with this nonsense.

He deleted the post because he asked you to take it to PMs, as to not take the thread further off topic. It had nothing to do with anything else.

Very simple.

And yes, I'm afraid he does have the right to edit posts -- As per the rules of this forum -- A moderator can edit any posts that they feel is detrimental. You continuing to take the thread off topic was such, hence why your post was deleted.

Your inability to understand this simple fact, and your continued thinking that your posts were deleted because you 'hurt his feelings' despite me telling you otherwise, is quite alarming.

And no, it all started because you had a nasty little attitude about the topic. Had you not been acting like a spoiled brat trying to prove your knowledge of a (shitty) show, and trying to take someone down a notch for a percieved error, then none of this would have happened, and you wouldn't be looking like a little baby right now.

I look forward to seeing Edie possibly survive her suicide attempt. DH is a good show, especially this past season was really good. Mike and Susan should be happy now and live well. Gaby and Carlos possibly back together, Eva and Marco have great chemistry together and that shows everytime they are on screen.

Spoiler:
they already said on tvguide that eddie will still be on the show, they gave a hint saying think about the fact she used a scarf which has no chance of holding any weight

InnerRise I really don't understand why you are still harping about this issue or why you feel the need to have the last word. Let's go over this. You're incorrect when you say that the problem start with my post. No, that was me responding to what you wrote. The problem started here:

Originally posted by InnerRise
Ummmm nooo.. The writers made it quite clear why Eddie killed herself and it didn't come across that she JUST KILLED HERSELF OVER A MAN. You just fail to GET IT, to UNDERSTAND IT.

It came across just as the writers intended and I GOT IT.

anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

The problem is this: You were telling me what I missed. Claiming that "The writers made it quite clear" . I have no problem people saying that I missed a point, if we're furthering the discussion. But the way you did this was a problem because:

a.) You said in a very rude and offensive way as if to say that it is so clear to everyone else but "I" just didn't get it. Basically implying that I'm dumb for not getting it.
b.) You never actually explained any of what I missed. All you kept saying was what I didn't get, what I didn't understand, etc. But you never came out and said, "You missed the part . . .." Therefore you never furthered the discussion.
c.) I and other mods have asked you to move on several times, you have not. You come back into the thread arguing why what you said wasn't rude, while ignoring half of everything mods have already said.

But even if you felt that you were right or whatever, all I asked was that you do not continue discussing this issue in this thread. Believe it or not, there there are members here who would actually like to talk about the show instead of coming into a thread, reading a page of this pity argument. So I invited you to further discuss this issue via PM. You decided that you were going to continue talking about it in this thread, even though I asked you not to, thereby distracting other posters who are trying to talk about the show.

So, again, this is a problem and this discussion is over with. Please move on. I apologize to other posters that were trying to discuss the show.

Originally posted by forumcrew

Spoiler:
they already said on tvguide that eddie will still be on the show, they gave a hint saying think about the fact she used a scarf which has no chance of holding any weight

Anata wa wakarimasu ka.....

I haven't been able to watch most of Desperate Housewives because of my new job-4-12pm but thank god for the internet did anyone catch the season finale? I thought it was quite good and look forward to the season premiere!