Originally posted by Morridini
I have actually explained this a couple of times in two other threads. But anyway. If we see the start of the Death Star in ROTS that would mean that the first DS would take about 20 years to be made. But during the time between ANH and ROTJ they managed to build an even larger and more powerful DS. This doesn't make sense. I know it's always easier to do something the second time, but an improvement on 16 years (give or take) is just too illogic, I just don't buy it. That's why I would hate seeing the DS in ROTS.
maybe they had more resistance (the empire that is) so it took a while to build it because of fighting and resource issues by the time they rebuilt it they were already the dominant force
I was hoping the last shot would be of Vader in action killing off Jedi. But that wouldn't really work because every Star Wars outro has to lead into the sort-of-happy ending music.
It seriously cannot end with someone evil in shot, the last shot WILL be of a good character. How else can it be done? How can you have the Star Wars jingle right after seeing Vader kill a load of Jedi or seeing the Death Star getting built?
The best possible ending would be Ben Kenobi walking off into the sunset after deliverring Luke.
BUT, just before that 'd go absolutely mental if we could see suited Vader leading the Stormtroopers into battle against the remaining Jedi.
I would wish both scenes as ending...
Imagine, after Vader is born, he walks to Tarkin and the Emperor and they talk about their ultimative weapon...
Cut to the scene where Obi-Wan is giving Luke to Owen and Beru, cut to Bail who is on Alderaan with his wife and Leia. Vader, Tarkin and Palpatine continuing talking about their weapon, cut to scene where Obi-Wan walks into the desert (now it's only music like in the previous SW-movies), the three evil persons are shown, the camera shows their view out of the window, rises and shows the Death Star, which is going to the built...
Maybe instead of the normal SW final music at the credits, at this time the Imperial March. 🙂
That would be a nice end. It seems the galaxy would be lost, the future would be dark, but there is still hope... a new hope. 😉
Bye
Lotus
Well, I was suggesting the good character ending because I seriously doubt they would break the mould of the last five movies by having anything other than the happy Star Wars jingle at the end.Obi-Wan leaving Luke and walking off into the two suns in the horizon would be brilliant imo. After all, the next chapter will be called "A New Hope" so it would be fitting for Episode III to end with a slight inspiration of hope. Also, ending Episode III with the Star Wars jingle would help lead into the next Episode, where that same jingle is the main theme in general.
OK, here's my idea:
*Padme dies, Vader is born, Yoda hides, twins get split up etc etc etc.*
*Emperor music starts up*
*Cue The Emperor on board a Star Destroyer stood with Tarkin overseeing his Empire beginning work on the Death Star. We hear The Emperor talking about his latest apprentice and how that the Rebellion will have NO HOPE with Vader on their side. We hear him cackling as the camera does a slow camera wipe*
*Imperial March starts as Emperor music ends*
*Camera wipe opens and we see an upclose shot of Vader, the camera pans out and we see him angrily breathing, marching with Stormtroopers as they barrage a small group of ten Jedi with laser fire. Vader cuts down three Jedi with ease himself. He duels shortly with the remaining Jedi as the Stormtroopers halt fire. Imperial March theme reaches it's dramatic climax - kinda like when Han is frozen in ESB. Vader overpowers a saber clash and grabs the Jedi by the throat. The camera zooms in on Vaders mask as the camera wipes out*
*Cue ending scene with Obi-Wan and Luke on Tatooine - leads into main credits*
With that ending, it will seem as though its all doom and gloom, but with a tiny, tiny glimpse of hope.
Originally posted by Morridini
I have actually explained this a couple of times in two other threads. But anyway. If we see the start of the Death Star in ROTS that would mean that the first DS would take about 20 years to be made. But during the time between ANH and ROTJ they managed to build an even larger and more powerful DS. This doesn't make sense. I know it's always easier to do something the second time, but an improvement on 16 years (give or take) is just too illogic, I just don't buy it. That's why I would hate seeing the DS in ROTS.
I think on the first DS they were building it in secrecy so it took them longer to build the first one. The second DS was built when the empire had complete control of the Galaxy. And also we don't know when the first DS was finished it just shows up in ANH complete. It could have been finished for a couple years. We really don't know but I think that would be the case.
Originally posted by Morridini
I have actually explained this a couple of times in two other threads. But anyway. If we see the start of the Death Star in ROTS that would mean that the first DS would take about 20 years to be made. But during the time between ANH and ROTJ they managed to build an even larger and more powerful DS. This doesn't make sense. I know it's always easier to do something the second time, but an improvement on 16 years (give or take) is just too illogic, I just don't buy it. That's why I would hate seeing the DS in ROTS.
i did not read any further but i have to reply to this,i mean come on you got a point for sure,but lets say no one knew about the death star until episode 4,that it took the same amount of time to build the first than the second!!!it hasent been said in the OT that the DS took 20 years to build!!!it ws just "opperational" in episode 4 thats all maybe took a year to build,who knows!!!AND LIKE I TOLD YOU B4 MORRIDINI,BUILDING SOMETHING A SECOND TIME IS WAY FASTER!