Justice League vs. Defenders

There are four heroes per team. No weapons are used, (exception: weapons normally possessed by that hero e.g.: Wonder Woman's lasso,) and No environmental advantages (such as entering space or the sea.) The contest would be on a surface similar to earths

Justice League:
Superman ("post crisis"😉
Wonder Woman (with power enhancement.)
Aquaman
Green Lantern

Defenders:
Dr. Strange
Hulk (Professor Hulk)
Silver Surfer (Uni-power)
Namor (the Sub-Mariner)

Superman would be faster than most of the defenders, except the Silver Surfer, and his strength rivals Hulk's. However he would be very susceptible to Dr. Strange's magic.

Dr. Strange's magic is very powerful, he can also fly, read minds, and possesses vast wisdom and battle experience. However he is not physically strong.

Wonder Woman's strength is only slightly less than Superman's with her enhancements, but can she withstand the power of the Uni force Silver Surfer possesses?

The Professor Hulk has Hulk's body and capacity for infinite strength, but also has Bruce Banner's genius level intellect. He is stronger than Superman, but he would have his hands full dealing with Superman's speed

Aquaman is powerful, and is armed with telepathic powers; however his strength is considerably less than Superman's or Wonder Woman's.

The Silver Surfer possesses the Uni-Power granted to him by his old master, Galactus. His strength is comparable to Hulk's base strength and is much, much, faster.

Green Lantern can use his ring to create green force fields. This ability could be countered by magic.

Namor has strength superior to Wonder Woman's, and the power of flight at his disposal. He also has limited invulnerability.

The Battle Goes to The Defenders. The Lite-Justice Leauge is of no comparsion. (You put Aquaman on the team?!) The Silver Surfer is stronger than any of them. Dr. Strange is master sorcerer. Hulk is smart for once. It's little biased for my taste. I would replace Aquaman for the Flash or Captain Marvel. The Justice League would put up a good fight but they're seriously outgunned. The way I see it one superspeed punch knocks out the good doctor. Superman and WW launch a superspeed assault on Namor. He goes down. After occupying the Hulk with giant plasma robot. Superman and WW tag team Hulk. He goes down. While Supes and WW fougnt the Hulk, Green Lantern fought the Silver Surfer. He loses. Silver Surfer blasts Supes and WW into oblivion. Aquaman is useless. He justs stands there waving a pompom made of seaweed. The Defenders win.

For the last flippin time, Wonder Woman is stronger than Namor. He's max is 75 tons. She can exceed 100! Good God! And she doen't need any power enhancements!

You're right about the fact that I may have decided upon the wrong justice league members, as I am not a justice league buff. I thought I was picking their best members, I could have chosen batman. However they still have more than a fighting chance. Aquaman has super-strengh and telepathy. I also doubt that Silver Surfer would take down Superman and Wonder Woman by himself when the Fantastic Four bested him. He would require assisitance from Dr. Strange in the very least. And for the last time Namor strength is at 85 tons, Wonder Woman's is undetermined, but proven to be less than Superman's. I hardly think that Professor Hulk's would waste his time fighting one of Green Lantern's plasma toys. He would likely strategize this battle with his genius level intelligence. And why would Dr. Strange be knocked out by a single "superspeed" punch (from superman, I suppose,) when he could use magic to protect himself and counterattack using magic, one of blue boy's glaring weaknesses? I too think the Defenders would win, but not under the pretenses portrayed in your story. It seems that you place the burden of this fight soley on the Silver Surfer. Speed isn't everything.

No Batman in your Justice League lineup? That's just wrong

Batman would be destroyed by any of the defenders. He never fought anyone as powerful. He should really stick to the likes of Joker and Two-face.

That sooooooo cold dude. Batman the guy that makes the plans. He has his purpose. The JLA need him and they know it and you know it.

I'm sorry but this isn't a popularity contest. He can make the plans, but he would be a burden to the team in battle. Hell, I like batman, but he's not on the level of the opposition.

Can Bruce Lee beat Superman?

You almost make me think you don't like the Batman dude. And Supersucks...I don't think Bruce Lee has a chance in hell.

My point exactly. No strategy could save batman from Dr. Strange, Namor, Hulk, and Silver Surfer, he's only human, and that's what we all love about him.

NO duuuuuu.... No one superhero could do that. But a highly skilled team such as the JLA could....Dammit !! I forgot about the Sliver Surfer The Defenders take it.

Here’s how the fight goes:

Dr. Strange uses his mind reading ability to find that Superman is susceptible to magic. He casts a spell on superman and drains him of his power. After this one punch from Hulk is more than enough to finish him. Wonder Woman hits Dr. Strange with a rising uppercut to finish him off. Silver Surfer and Wonder Woman battle, but his superior strength and speed allows him to overcome her. Aquaman charges the Silver Surfer from his blindside and uses his telepathy to subdue him. Namor is being held in a force field generated by Green Lantern, but it dissipates after Hulk delivers a crushing blow to the back of his head. Namor and Hulk double team Aquaman, who in turn uses his mind control to overcome Hulk. Namor, is stronger than Aquaman, and possesses the power of flight, so it is easy for Namor him to overcome him.

defenders although I did pit the same for but different incarnations against the x-treme x-men. but they had the numbers advantage.
and I didn't state the incarnations.

Justice League:
Superman ("post crisis"😉
Wonder Woman (with power enhancement.)
Aquaman
Green Lantern

Defenders:
Dr. Strange
Hulk (Professor Hulk)
He's excess of Class 100 strenght, but more vulnerable than savage Hulk, maybe he would give WW hard time, remember Hulk's reflexes and speed are superhuman too, but finally he goes down.They wouldn't give him the chance to become a real problem.
Silver Surfer (Uni-power)
He can wipe out Superman, and even if the Man Of Steel gives him troubles, Supes would fall under a mystical energy bolt from Dr. Strange
Namor (the Sub-Mariner)
Out of Water Namor is Class 70, he still posses superhuman resistance to injury, stamina, reflexes, and fly, he would wipe out Aquaman, the worst member of that JLA incarnation, then would get knocked down from Supes or WW.
If GL is Kyle Rainer, he falls.If it's Hal Jordan or John Stewart, then they could give SS troubles, especially Hal would be able to win, but i give this to Surfer.
Finally the Surfer, and Dr. Strange triumph.Defenders 1, JLA 0.

I wouldn't put Professor out of the fight so quickly

whith the team members you choose i woudl say defenders, instead of aquaman you should choose Martian Manhunter.

I'm thinks justice league would win, but thats just me.

Surfer could kill all of the Justice league members, including MM.

I'm thinking green latern can kick a lot of the defenders. Why do you think surfer could kill all of the justice league members?

Surfer can kill superman by absorbing his sunlight using his energy manipulation power. He can also absorb the energy of the green lantern's ring. Green Lanturn couldn't handle any of the defenders.