Batgirl vs. Robin vs. Harley Quinn

Three contenders from Gotham who have been called side kicks at various times, and who have decided in this battle to go it alone... so which of the three would out think, out fight and end up winning over the over two?

Note - The battle has no prep time, but takes place in a small village, around which are littered various weapons and tools the contenders are familiar with...

which batgirl and which robin?

Robin's highly skilled at hand-to-hand, knowing styles that even Batman hasn't learned, but I still don't think he could hang with Batgirl's skills. Harley's a low-level meta, so that would definitely put things in her favor, don't know just how much in her favor though.

the giant mallet'd help...

Which Robin Dick, Jason or Tim? The current Batgirl kicks A$$!!!!

Dick is now Nightwing, Jason is dead, and Tim I believe is still a minor and will be distracted with other things when facing these two females. Harley can have more tricks up her sleeve than Joker if she wanted to, but Batgirl (Cassandra as Barbara is now Oracle) is a stronger fighter and would probably win overall.

Or the Spoilor, There are 4 Robins, now, One of them is a girl.

And 2 dead Robins, Yes the Spoiler was killed. I was pretty sad to see it.

There was a girl, but I thought she made only one appearance?

I have 2 comics with the Spoiler as Robin.,

She would get killed not to long after that.

She is Tim Drakes girl freind, and was the crime fighter Spoiler, Who Cain train with(In Barbs tower.)

She was a better Robin than Spoiler IMO. I like her better than Tim, and JAson, But Dick is always tops.

Stephine was her real name. It was in recent comics. Hush. I think,

Originally posted by radioboy121
Dick is now Nightwing, Jason is dead, and Tim I believe is still a minor and will be distracted with other things when facing these two females. Harley can have more tricks up her sleeve than Joker if she wanted to, but Batgirl (Cassandra as Barbara is now Oracle) is a stronger fighter and would probably win overall.

What would Tim be distracted by exactly? Tim's had a few f*cked up years as of late, but the leader of the Teen Titans has no problem keeping his focus against these two women, teenage hormones or not. Hand-to-hand, he may still lose to Cass, but he's nearly as tricky as Batman, so that's a plus.

Tron, I don't discount Tim's skills in both tactical and leadership levels, but he would not edge Batgirl in this fight, especially since she possesses relatively similar aspects. As to the hormone reasoning, I was being humorous, but still I'm sure this is in his mind, unless he's completely sterile.