Will Episode III surpass any of the OT movies? [Merged]

Originally posted by Alatopel
Episode III has it's plot pretty much set in stone. Lucas cannot change too many things without creating giant plotholes the size of Endor. Why Endor, and not the Death Star, since the second is cooler, I have no idea. But, back on topic again.

We all know what will happen, regardless of spoilers or not. Lucas knows this. He has to find some way to keep this interesting for us, as well as keeping the story what we wanted - introduce, General Grevous. The lines, I'm hoping, will be better than I and II, though the original trilogy was no shakespear, those two were horrid when compared to the OT. If he manages to get the plot to be complex, yet not so complex that it confuses people, yet not too simple that nothing happens, it should work. That was the beauty of ESB - many things happened, but they all were easily kept into perspective. Lando turning good was caused by Vader changing the deal. Han and Leia fell in love because they just kept getting into those situations. And so on. I'm gonna stop here before I start to go into a -real- rant.

Well

Spoiler:
the whole Yoda arrogant and him being responsible for the fall of the Jedi

Originally posted by LandoSpeeder2
Well

Spoiler:
the whole Yoda arrogant and him being responsible for the fall of the Jedi

was a huge shocker for me, and I think their will be more stuff that will shock the audience.

In answering the previous question about which of the trilogies is third-best, I'd say Jedi, but not because of the Ewoks or teh "party" scene at the end. It was the cartoony and almost sellout nature of the whole thing. It was basically to sellJabba playsets by that point. That fact notwithstanding, the movie has some great moments...

Admiral Ackbar: Itshh a trap!

Best line ever.

Okay, who thinks that Revenge of the Sith will be the Greatest Star Wars Movie?

best thread ever...

Where is my gun??? 😑

Are you implying that this is a useless thread because we all know that it will be the greatest?

Or did you mean something else? Let me know. I don't quite understand

Im implying that you've opened 3 threads in the last half hour that could have been avoided by using the search button. Is that clear, or do you need me to draw you a picture?

How are we supposed to know if it will ne the greatest Star Wars movie if we haven't even seen it yet?

I think you'd better draw him the picture 😉

Wheres another poll like this one? I don't think there is one

Dude you got here a month ago, this section has been here 2 years. Are you saying in all that time no one else has ever thought of this idea for a thread? Use the search button.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Im implying that you've opened 3 threads in the last half hour that could have been avoided by using the search button. Is that clear, or do you need me to draw you a picture?

No, especially since Episode 1 and 2 blew goat balls.

okay. okay. I get the idea. But alot of people could have changed their minds. After all these tv spots and stuff.

sorry........

I'm really sorry. But I beg to let this thread stay. Because i'd really like to see what people think NOW. after seeing the TV Spots.

I will never do anything screwy again, if you leave this thread going. And please, can people vote? Thank you so much.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Im implying that you've opened 3 threads in the last half hour that could have been avoided by using the search button. Is that clear, or do you need me to draw you a picture?

I don't mean to be a smartass, and I'm not taking MacGeek's side, but how would one go about drawing a picture of that?

Sorry, I kinda do mean to be a smartass. 😮

Originally posted by Torik_Shai
I don't mean to be a smartass, and I'm not taking MacGeek's side, but how would one go about drawing a picture of that?

Sorry, I kinda do mean to be a smartass. 😮

Look, I said I was sorry. But can people please vote?

This is looking nice. Just like I thought. 6 to 0.

I just wanna see one of JP's drawings 🙂

me too