Originally posted by amity75
I can't believe people are criticising the emperors look. Lucas must sit and wonder why he bothers to make the films when so many people nitpick at the smallest things. Just go and enjoy the movie and put these small things to the back of your minds.
i sit and wonder why he bothers to make the films if he's going to make them full of so many plot holes, bad acting, cheezy dialogue, and utter let downs such as the makeup for the emperor. amity, it is the small things, the nuance that makes great movies great. and yes, i do plan to enjoy the movie as best i can, but some of this shit needs venting... also, if no one ever sat around and bickered like this, there'd be no motivation for some complacent directors to strive to be better in hopes of avoiding pissing off the multitudes of fans who are NOT willing to turn a blind eye to so many things.
my BIGGEST annoyance with Lucas is how he can spend so much time adding new scenes to the movies whilst leaving sucky ones in.
Example- the scene in A NEW HOPE where after r5 blows up at lukes side you can still see him beside r2 when lukes says "uncle Owen what about that one?" and the Imperial officer in the freezing chamber in ESB with the uk then us accent...sloppy.
WE dont get much REAL dialogue in the prequels.....we mainly get soundbites that sound cool
"dont move jedi"
"this partys over"
"we havent much time"
etc
i dont have a problem with the Emperors make up at all tho
ehmmmm, i liked a new hope for the innovation.... innovation just in special effects cause its a huge collage of all genere films, wich is not bad, i love empire and return of the jedi i only like jabba and the end the confrontation with vader.... i hated phantom menace because of all the bad decisions taken, but i liked it a lot more than attack of the clones wich was all eye candy and they put jandgo fett as a marketing technique. That pisses me off, i grew up watching star wars, of course i like it, and because of that I'm really angry to what lucas did.... he did something great to hollywood then he messed it up. f you are so lind and such a fanatic that you dont believe, see the special edition of THX where lucas himself admits that he doesnt know how to write and that THX is his proudest proyect and that he has become what he most hated. Even Coppola said that he cant write good lines, his own teacher. Thats why I'm so angry at him.... he created a lot of good stuff that changed the wolrd of cinema once and then he became the nw moster for the medium. He turned to the dark sie to put it in SW terms. Atleast i have good reasons to say what i say, mst of you likes whatever they put you on screen, cause its star wars. have some reason for christ sake.
the worst thing about certain sw fans is the way they get all huffy if you critisize anything SW
i consider myself an sw fan but its 6 years since Phantom Menace and i STILL havent decided if i like it or not
i find myself being a fan of bits of the prequels rather the whole
BUT so far what im seeing and hearing of EP3 i like
i remember reading the screenplay of TPM and thinking is THAT IT???
this time round things are different there is a totally diff vibe about this one
DARKNESS.......it was hinted at in ep2 and its all im getting from this one
"Little children may be scared by Episode 3"
HOORAH!
Originally posted by GangularisHow so? If someone was a true fan they wouldn't try and find something wrong with everything. These are the people who become movie critics, Professional Overanalists I like to call them. They strive to ruin everyones experience by giving there opinions and passing them off as fact. Total BS!
but it didn't get worse over 20 years, because you see him looking all rubber faced in ESB now.btw, it is complete bullshit for you to pull the "you're not a true star wars fan" line.
Originally posted by .😖pace Opera:.Yea people have there own opinions but they should be prepared for repercussions for there actions. I have my opinion and I posted it. I think this guy is nothing but a troll and should be banned! There... another opinion for ya SO.
"Dude, if you were a real SW fan you wouldn't have even posted this crap much less have your forum name as LUCAS SUCKS. I think you are just trying to piss people off. "DUDE, not all SW fans think alike! if that were the case then there'd be no forums!
Originally posted by XamAnd I was expressing mine! 😠
i just dint read wat he said i just did not like wat JediJunky wrote,we all alowd to our own opinion!
Look I didn't mean to piss people off. I just think that this guy is trying to get under people's skins. I can't believe that you guys (who I truly think are GREAT FANS) are defending this guy.
Have to admit though, after seein the ROTS trailer the makeup in Empire does look a bit weird, unless Yoda F£$ks him up! but then it doesn't look all that consistent with the ROTJ make up either, maybe more so than the original Empire makeup but still not quite right! i dunno think we'll have to wait for ROTS
have a read everyone: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/misc.php?action=rules