"Phantom of the Opera" (2004)

I'm sticking by my decision. Gerard's singing voice lacked character and the Phantom in the movie wasn't threatening enough. In the play they made him out to be so much more frightening yet sympathetic. In the movie it was like, "I'm sexy but misunderstood!". The Phantom was a monster in every aspect. Emmy was good for her age but her voice wasn't powerful and it didn't have any emotion like Sarah Brightman. I actually loved the girl I saw in the current season's production at Her Majesty's Theatre. Honestly, she was singing through tears near the end and it was amazing. The originals will never be beaten in any form.

I think Emmy Rossum did the best. She was great at being Christine.

I still think that everyone in the movie did AWESOME! and the originals were great too!

I'm a huge fan of Phantom. I have yet to see the broadway show. I will one of these days. I have this movie on DVD. The cast is wonderful. I really enjoyed it.

Andrew, I agree with you 100%. Gerard was a terrible disappointment. Emmy was ok though

I love this movie so much, it is so romantic

me too..its my second favourite movie! ✅

I think my moms getting tickets to see it on Broadway 😊

i did not like the movie at all i thought it was an extream injustice to the work itself which is a masterpiece. Christine had this problem of not sounding like a grown up and the phantom could not hit the notes half of the time the only people i was impressed with were Meg and Carlotta i believe meg should have gotten christine her voice was more mature and she was not bad at acting but christine is such a demanding part you cant give her to an actress which is what they did cause she couldnt sing thats a deffinent but you know that my opinion

by the way if you loved this movie its beutifull i would recommend seeing it at the theatre the intimacy is so much more and if you go to New York you may see me i dont know but we just celebrated the 2139th showing which is now the longest running show on broadway... see it on stage it is so much better and most of you will understand what i mean about the movie not coming across as well

I saw it on broadway!!! I loved it! I'm so addicted to it, I've downloaded the all thje songs and ordered them like in the movie 😮