Darth Malak vs. Darth Maul

Sidious isn't extremely better than Revan. If he was, he would have openly attacked Jedi knights and destroyed them in legion. The old fart had Annie (Little Annie) and about a bajillion clone troopers killing Jedi. Devious, clever, but ultimately WEAK.

Man is good, I give you that, but he's no warrior Sith lord.

Good point. If he was so strong he would not care if a few scattered jedi opposed him. 🤣

He has his own style....which happens to have worked. He's better IMHO....a lot better.

He has his own style. Wow, let me rethink my decision.

Uh, no.

Sidious was not able to openly challenge and defeat every Jedi who came up against him. If he was that badass, he would have done away with Anakin and been the only Force user alive.

close but id say maul.no malak

Alright, to be a fair guy, I went and watched Maul's fight scene at the end of the Phantom Menace. And it was a lot better than I remember. Maul was very acrobatic and deft, and he at least appeared to be in some measure of control, though his restlessness and overconfidence would ultimately be his glaring weaknesses. (Not as if Malak isn't overconfidant and restless)

And looking at all his moves, his stance, his face even as he fought, Maul's good. But I seriously doubt he can compare with Malak's experience. In terms of experience, Maul is akin to an army cadet one year or two out of training, whereas Malak is a captain who's made a military career out of his experiences.

Maul would win he probably has much better saber skills and he does have great force powers it just is not shown in the movie BECAUSE HE DIDN'T NEED TO USE THEM, so i say Maul would kill him

He didn't need them? He freaking died, he needed them... He needed them badly, if you are stupid enough to let an opponent defeat you because you think you don't need to use the force then your not much of a fighter to begin with...

Malak was, he knew better then to make mistakes from all the combat experience he has seen, he has fought more opponents then Maul could even hope of and he always won. Besides he has a lot more experience then Maul

Originally posted by Jaster Fett
Maul would win he probably has much better saber skills and he does have great force powers it just is not shown in the movie BECAUSE HE DIDN'T NEED TO USE THEM, so i say Maul would kill him

Let me dissect this hastily written reply.

Note, subject has posted "he probably has much better skills saber skills".

That's quite an assumption. I probably might make a million dollars this year. Might not. Can I buy a house in Cancun? Not with a probability.

He didn't need to use them, you say? Is that why he's in two pieces as the bottom of some shaft in Naboo?

Last question, do you even know who Malak is?

I agree with Janus but Jaster is right in the fact that Maul didn't need to use the Force powers, he just got arrogant. Though there's still no way his force powers could match Malak's.

Maul would rock out with his cock out, and slap malak across the face with it, then kill em.

darth maul

I'd give this one to Darth Maul.