The Riddler vs. The Joker

Someone made this thread before like two seconds ago
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t408874.html

Someone else made a thread like this about 6 or 7 months ago:
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t375906.html

And one back in February: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=390625&highlight=joker+riddler

it's been made and JOOOOKKKKKERRRRRRR wins.

Well, it's been said that Riddler could possibly be more of a JLA level threat, if it weren't for his obsession with riddles and puzzles.

Can the Riddler take out the Joker with a month of prep?

Originally posted by seaapple
Can the Riddler take out the Joker with a month of prep?

With a month of prep?

Hells yes.

has something like this happen in comics? and if not WHY THE HELL NOT!

id love to see joker trying to pull his way threw a month worths of planing from the riddler.

Riddler would take joker out. in a comic book get damn close.

[Edited]

Is that the general consensus? I thought the Joker might be considered to be of a high enough level that he might be tough for the Riddler. Actually I like the Riddler better...

Well, in theory, Riddler should definitely be able to take him with a month of prep, but the Joker is pure chaos, he's too unpredictable to really say that he has NO chance. He can always do something completely unexpected and perhaps come through.

Question is, is the Riddler the only one that has prep? If the Joker has prep as well, Riddler aint doing it imo.

Yeah, jrod, I think you might be right. However, I believe the thread indicates that only Riddler gets prep. It would still be a GREAT comic to read, even if Joker got prep too. I don't know why this hasn't been done.

Meh. Riddler's smarter than the Joker, but wouldn't use his prep as aptly, just because he'd set it up as more of a game, playing mind games with Joker, whereas Joker would probably just trap Riddler and kill him if he had prep

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
Meh. Riddler's smarter than the Joker, but wouldn't use his prep as aptly, just because he'd set it up as more of a game, playing mind games with Joker, whereas Joker would probably just trap Riddler and kill him if he had prep

Cause the Joker never plays games with his victims?

Originally posted by Soljer
Cause the Joker never plays games with his victims?

Joker terrorizes them. Riddler toys with them.

Originally posted by SpookySmurph
Not like Riddler, no.

Joker terrorizes them. Riddler toys with them.

I could see the Joker setting up a SAW-like scenario and the Riddler being smart enough to get out of it...

Originally posted by Soljer
I could see the Joker setting up a SAW-like scenario and the Riddler being smart enough to get out of it...

In Hush, Riddler was manipulating everyone to break Batman down piece by piece. Joker didn't want to participate, until he heard about "The Jason Todd gag".

Where as, when Joker wanted to take down President Lex Luthor, he prepped a little, but did it fast, swift, and in a much more deadly fashion, iirc.

Riddler wins. I have no idea why he isn't featured more often!

yes he would

It would be cool has hell to see this happen

I'm glad you guys like my thread here for a change! The Riddler is a classy character. I also would like to see him used more.