ROTS Anakin versus ROTJ Luke

Sure it would. Victory for Luke. He gets to run off to the swamp and perhaps learn some moves that just might confuse his father enough to score a lethal blow.

Yeah well, i was just trying to point out the concept that if you are fighting somebody and you run away like a sissy, that does not really count as a victory. I did not say, hey if Luke runs away to the swamp, trains and learns new abilities, then re-challenges Anakin and beats him, that is no victory.

I think you need to train yourself better in the ways of sarcasm, my friend.

I think you need to stop splitting hairs

oooooo

ahhhhhhhhh

Anakin would tear luke's ass up

You're a rather volatile one, aren't you? Sorry to have irked you. Didn't realize you had so much at stake in this.

Apology accepted

basically everyone here agrees that Anakin will annihilate Luke

Luke would fold like burning paper. No question there.

Shouldnt this go in the Versus section?

There are half a dozen posts like this scattered throughout the SW forum that should be in Versus.

Originally posted by Arsenal
Father versus Son

Anakin, No contest.....

Originally posted by Arsenal
Arsenal

nothing to do with thread but i like the signature arsenal.
would you mind if i used? fav char is darth maul.
Plz pm me a response.
Thanks

I keep re-thinking this and considering Obi-Wan had the skills to turn Anakin's strength's against him, I think Luke, (at this point has surpassed episode 3 Obi-Wan) would actually get the W.

Lukes weak and stupid, i still think to this day that Vader should of beat him in ROTJ, Vader has had years of experence with the force and with the use of his light sabre, and Lukes had what?!?! like 1/2 weeks Jedi training with Yoda what i felt kinda stupid. And Vader got beaten, hes not even that old ffs, Vader was what? 40-50? thats not that old

I reckon luke would win
seeing that he killed robot vader i thnk he would kill anakin in rots

Luke would gets his ass handed to him by a youngling from the mighty bear clan. There are plenty of times in Empire and ROTJ where Vader could have easily striked down Luke but that wasn't his goal. He wanted to turn his son not kill him. Just watch the movie and count how many times Vader has the opportunity to kill the farmboy but holds back.

luke sucks, he so weak, he even finds it hard to use the force to pick up C3PO and make him look like hes got powers in ROTJ

Originally posted by Uber_God
I reckon luke would win
seeing that he killed robot vader i thnk he would kill anakin in rots

bullshit, you think that luke would loose because episode 6 was made when there were not so good effects, if they would be making it now, they would make such a fight, that there would be no argues,basically anakin in ROTS is the same as Darth Veder in ROTJ, the only difference is that there were no video effects to make fight better, and one more thing it is not realated to post, but anyway, Windu will kick everybody's ass. By the way Luke clearly kicked his father's ass in episode 6.

but that was vader at half of hte strength he has in ROTS, so really, I was wrong Luke will die.

But Luke is the new hope and all so he might possibly only have his hand cut off.